Submit a Story!
David S. Broder on Harry Reid's Opt-Out Plan on the Public Option
There is an air of desperate improvisation to Sen. Harry Reid's scheme to pass a "public option" as part of health-care reform but at the same time provide an easy exemption for any state that objects to it. The warning flags ought to be flying for anyone who can count to three -- let alone 60.
Will Reid's Public Option Health Gamble Pay Off?
Will Reid's Public Option Health Gamble Pay Off?
time.com — Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid has decided he has the votes to get a health reform bill... with a public option to the Senate floor. Does he have the votes it will take to get it out of the Chamber? (more) Will Reid's Public Option Health Gamble Pay Off?
insurance bill will include opt
washingtonpost.com — Comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from... the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. ... (more) insurance bill will include opt
So What Is the 'Opt-Out' Compromise?
talkingpointsmemo.com — Sen. Reid's announcement today is just one more increment in the progress of health care reform. But... it is worth stepping back to note the importance that an outside-the-box idea can have in significantly changing the terms of a major policy debate. ... (more) So What Is the 'Opt-Out' Compromise?
Comments
Blog Reactions

MATLOCK!!!
Firedoglake — I guess I can understand David Broder not being cognizant of using “the Google”, though basic history awareness would be nice, but how about his editors engaging in some fact checking? But then maybe ol’ Davey, George Will and Krauthammer share the same editor? That’s a lot of error for one person to catch. Today “the Dean” says this: ...

MATLOCK!!!
Rising Hegemon — I guess I can understand David Broder not being cognizant of using "the Google", though basic history awareness would be nice, but how about his editors engaging in some fact checking? But then maybe ol' Davey, George Will and Krauthammer share the same editors? That's a lot of error for one person to catch. Today "the Dean" says this: Consider the precedent that would be set if a major piece of social legislation were to be passed with a states' rights provision. Imagine, for example, if Franklin Roosevelt had ...

Truly a moronic column from David Broder
Open Left - Quick Hits's RSS Feed — ... the entire column: "Rather than bring a bill without the public option to the Senate floor and then hope to merge it in conference with a House bill almost certain to include such a provision, Reid bent to the political pressure and put his own needs first." Why,  one might ask,  cannot  the same logic  be applied to the opt-out? Ahh, but then there would be no point to the Broder column. And newspapers wonder why their circulation is falling. Hint. http://www.washingtonpost.com/...

Related Content
David S. Broder
washingtonpost.com 11/14/2009 — Comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. ...
Harry Reid Announces Plan For Public Option With Opt-Out Option
liberalvaluesblog.com 10/26/2009 — The public option has probably received more attention than any other aspect of health care reform even though it will only affect a minority of people who are eligible to select it. Harry Reid announced today the Senate bill will include a public option with an opt-out provision for states ...
Reports: Reid's Bill Is Ready, Includes 'Opt Out' Public Option
tpmlivewire.talkingpointsmemo.com 10/26/2009 — According to news reports, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid is sending the Senate's health care bill to the Congressional Budget Office today, and may unveil the bill publicly as early as tomorrow. MSNBC, Reuters, the Wall Street Journal, CNN, Fox... ...
The When, How, Who, and What of the Public Option Opt-Out
fdlaction.firedoglake.com 10/26/2009 — Several news sources are reporting that Harry Reid plans to put a national public option with an opt-out provision in the merged Senate bill. So far, there have been almost zero details on how this national public option with an opt-out provision ...
Reid's choice an opt-out
politico.com 10/26/2009 — My colleague Glenn Thrush has some deets on Reid's afternoon announcement: Senate Majority Leader will announce this afternoon that he plans to push ahead with a public option vote that includes an opt-out provision for states even though he's ...
Opt-out public option
krugman.blogs.nytimes.com 10/9/2009 — At first blush, it sounds good.
Harry Reid Announces Plan For Public Option With Opt-Out Provision
feedproxy.google.com 10/26/2009 — The public option has probably received more attention than any other aspect of health care reform even though it will only affect a minority of people who are eligible to select it. Harry Reid announced today the Senate bill will include a public option with an opt-out provision for states ...
Reid Announces Opt-Out Public Option, But What Kind Of Plan Would States Opt-Out Of?
wonkroom.thinkprogress.org 10/27/2009 — This afternoon, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) announced that the merged Senate health bill would establish a national public option that allows states to opt out of the plan by 2014. Reid did not indicate that he had 60 votes in support of ...
Senator Reid Announces 'Opt-Out' Public Plan
prescriptions.blogs.nytimes.com 10/26/2009 — After two weeks of deliberation, the Senate majority leader, Harry Reid, will announce a compromise public plan to be included in the Senate's health care legislation.
Bear In Mind: Reid's Public Option NOT For Everyone
librarygrape.com 10/27/2009 — One thing that I didn't take away from the news reports today about Harry Reid's announcement about the inclusion of a public option in the bill that will be presented to the Senate for a floor vote is this: REID'S BILL ONLY ALLOWS PEOPLE WITHOUT HEALTH INSURANCE TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THE ...
Reid Lacks Votes for Health Insurance Public Option (Bloomberg)Yahoo! News: Politics News 10/28/2009
Bloomberg - Oct. 28 (Bloomberg) -- U.S. Senate Democratic Leader Harry Reid doesn’t have the 60 votes he needs to win approval of a government-run health-insurance program.
Reid Lacks Votes for Health Insurance Public Option (Bloomberg)Yahoo! News: Politics News 10/28/2009
Bloomberg - Oct. 28 (Bloomberg) -- U.S. Senate Democratic Leader Harry Reid doesn’t have the 60 votes he needs to win approval of a government-run health-insurance program.
David S. Broder on Harry Reid's Opt-Out Plan on the Public OptionWash Post In Congress 10/29/2009
No one should be denied health care by virtue of their place of birth.
Reid Sets Up Vote on Tax Extensions in Jobless Bill (CQPolitics.com)Yahoo! News: Politics News 10/30/2009
CQPolitics.com - The extension and expansion of a tax credit for first-time homebuyers has been incorporated into Senate legislation that would extend unemployment benefits.
Reid pushes public option amid 'Reid fatigue' in NevadaCNN.com - Politics 10/31/2009
Democratic strategists say while Harry Reid seeks to calm a liberal base on health care reform there is a different motivation at home in Nevada: a tough re-election battle.