Submit a Story!
FactChecking Debate No. 1
FactChecking Debate No. 1
Facts muddled in Mississippi McCain-Obama meeting.
Comments
Blog Reactions

Saturday Reading: Chukotka
Ben Smith's Blog — Only 21% of households watched the debate on braodcast, though the cable numbers aren't in yet. There were a number of venial sins of fact in a remarkably deep, fair policy debate. People hear what they are primed to hear -- it's a remarkable illusion -- but Andrew Sullivan walks back the viral rumor of the day. A Greenberg focus group underscores the new Obama-won CW. Nate Silver seeks to explain it. Plouffe tries his hand at raising Palin debate expectations. (Good luck with that.) Ambinder ...

Both Candidates Made Misstatements, But McCain's Were By A Mile
Politics on HuffingtonPost.com — I've put together a summary of the misstatements of fact in last night's debate as tracked by FactCheck.org. The bottom-line is that while Obama did make a few mistakes, none were outright fabrications, and even when wrong, he was fairly close to being accurate. McCain, on the other hand, delivered several whoppers that weren't even close to the truth. First, Obama's misstatements: Denied voting for a budget plan that called for a tax increase on people making $42K. He did vote for a budget resolution with such a recommendation, but even if ...

Both Candidates Made Misstatements, But McCain's Were By A Mile
The Huffington Post | Full News Feed — I've put together a summary of the misstatements of fact in last night's debate as tracked by FactCheck.org. The bottom-line is that while Obama did make a few mistakes, none were outright fabrications, and even when wrong, he was fairly close to being accurate. McCain, on the other hand, delivered several whoppers that weren't even close to the truth. First, Obama's misstatements: Denied voting for a budget plan that called for a tax increase on people making $42K. He did vote for a budget resolution with such a recommendation, but even if ...

Monday morning links
Maggie's Farm — ... stench from Missouri What's a POSSLQ? National elections build characters. LA Times Obama in Leftland. Gelernter in Wkly Std Global warming has paused. Why not say "stopped," and has begun to reverse itself? How the NYT blames Bush for the banking problems. Amazing. Related: Mankiw on distorting history Rick Moran answers your questions about the debate. Related: Fact-checking the debate. But what do facts matter? This election is about feelings, not facts. ...

Republicans Wanted to Regulate Freddie & Fannie, Democrats Didn’t See a Problem
Stones Cry Out — ... And by the way, where’s the MSM on this?  Quiet as a mouse.  FactCheck.org’s checking of debate facts is silent on this issue.  The objectivity on this issue is pointing out some glaring blind spots. ...

FactChecking the First Debate
Real Clear Politics - TIME.comFactCheck.org takes a look at some of claims in the first debate. Here's some of what it found: * Kissinger did say he wanted "high level" talks with Iran, but, despite what Obama claimed, he didn't say at the presidential level. * Obama did vote to raise taxes on people making as little as $42,000 a year, despite his denial. * Although Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman Admiral Mike Mullen did say a time line for withdrawal could be “very dangerous,” he was not talking specifically about Obama’s plan, as McCain claimed. * Earmark appropriations have decreased over the years, ...

Income disparity and "Middle Class" assumptions
The Reaction — ... comment: I know that the worst thing we could possibly do is to raise taxes on anybody, and a lot of people might be interested in Senator Obama's definition of "rich." (you can simultaneously read the transcript and watch the video here; clip begins at 11: 25 and the exact comment is made at 18:55). According to Factcheck.org: Obama's plan will cut the taxes for 95% of families with children and 81.3% of households overall. (citation) "Obama's plan would raise taxes only on individuals making ...

Related Content
A New Bad Habit
corner.nationalreview.com 9/27/2008 — More than one person noticed that Obama repeatedly referred to McCain as 'John.' It seems that Obama has picked up this bad habit from his running mate. During the primaries the RNC did research and found that Hillary gained sympathy from listeners ...
"John Was Right"
washingtonmonthly.com 9/27/2008 — "John Was Right" Last night, the fact that Obama said that McCain was right on several occasions caused consternation among some liberals, and great rejoicing on the right. I didn't agree. It would have been one thing had Obama not...
Why Obama Won Big
andrewsullivan.theatlantic.com 9/27/2008 — Nate Silver is a must-read . This is a fascinating nugget: The CBS poll of undecideds has more confirmatory detail. Obama went from a +18 on "understanding your needs and problems" before the debate to a +56 (!) afterward. And he went ...
I took a million notes during the debate....
jamesfallows.theatlantic.com 9/27/2008 — ... but let me boil it down to this: When the details of this encounter fade, as they soon will, I think the debate as a whole will be seen as of a piece with Kennedy-Nixon in 1960, Reagan-Carter in 1980, and Clinton-Bush in 1992. In each of those ...
On strategy and tactics
jamesfallows.theatlantic.com 9/27/2008 — The least self-aware moment for John McCain in last night's debate came at the half-way point, when he said, "I'm afraid Senator Obama doesn't understand the difference between a tactic and a strategy." In a sense McCain was sticking to his battle ...
Obama slams McCain for not mentioning middle classL.A. Times - Politics 9/27/2008
Greensboro, N.C. -- Democratic presidential candidate Barack Obama today called Republican rival John McCain out of touch with middle-class Americans, telling supporters that the GOP senator never once uttered the words "middle class" during their ...
Obama-Biden focus on 'middle class' fightFirst Read 9/27/2008
From NBC/NJ's Athena Jones and Mike Memoli GREENSBORO, NC -- Obama kept the focus on the economy Saturday, arguing at a North Carolina rally that last night’s debate showed McCain was out of touch with the concerns of ordinary Americans who ...
Next up: Biden and PalinCNN Political Ticker 9/27/2008
(CNN) – Now that Sens. Barack Obama and John McCain have their first presidential debate out of the way, the focus turns to their running mates. Sen. Joe Biden and Gov. Sarah Palin will face off Thursday at Washington University in St. Louis, ...
Next up: Biden and PalinCNN.com - Politics 9/27/2008
Now that Sens. Barack Obama and John McCain have their first presidential debate out of the way, the focus turns to their running mates.
Kissinger defends McCain on Iranian relationsCNN.com - Politics 9/27/2008
Former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger defended Sen. John McCain in his attack against Sen. Barack Obama for being willing to meet with Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad "without precondition."