motherjones.com - 3/27/2009
—
This morning, after President Barack Obama unveiled his new Afghanistan policy, three senior administration officials held an on-the-record (but no cameras) briefing for White House reporters. Ambassador Richard Holbrooke, the special envoy for Afghanistan and Pakistan, Bruce Riedel, chair of ...
michaelyon-online.com - 3/27/2009
—
michaelyon-online.com —
27 March 2009 President Obama has just spoken
on AfPak. I closed my eyes and listened closely...
to his words, coming via the BBC from the other side of the world. The President's words were disappointing. He talked about our goal to reach a force ...
(more)
Obama on Afghanistan: Disappointing
nytimes.com - 3/27/2009
—
nytimes.com —
Washington, DC March 27, 2009 Good morning. Today,
I am announcing a comprehensive, new strategy for Afghanistan...
and Pakistan. This marks the conclusion of a careful policy review that I ordered as soon as I took office. My Administration has heard ...
(more)
Text - President Obama’s Remarks on New Strategy ...
commentarymagazine.com - 3/27/2009
—
commentarymagazine.com —
The new Afghanistan policy that President Obama unveiled
at the White House today was pretty much all...
that supporters of the war effort could have asked for, and probably pretty similar to what a President McCain would have decided on. The major ...
(more)
A New Counterinsurgency in Afghanistan
Comments
Blog Reactions
The Drug War And Afghanistan
The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan —
David Corn noticed a really interesting nugget in Holbrooke's briefing:
What to do about the opium flowing out of Afghanistan has always been a knotty element of US policy regarding Afghanistan. How much of a priority should it be? (Simply put, if you attack the the opium ...
OBAMA’S AFPAK PLAN JUST ABOUT RIGHT
Right Wing Nut House —
... forces in Afghanistan. If there were not people like Gates and Petraeus up there, my gut would say to pull out. It is only my faith in the military, and what I saw them accomplish against heavy odds in Iraq, that gives me hope. I would add to Petreaus and Gates the name of Richard Holbrooke. This is one tough dude who also has the courage and ability to think outside the box. Here he talks about corruption and the huge challenge facing both the US and the Karzai government in dealing with the problem: I would just point you to the fact that no American chief executive has ...
Ambassador Richard Holbrooke: US has to completely rethink drugs policy in Afghanistan
PoliGazette —
... Finally: one of the top advisers to President Barack Obama has said the U.S. has to “completely rethink” its drugs policy in Afghanistan. ...
Weekend Opinionator: The Art of War in Afghanistan
Opinionator —
... “Holbrooke said the $800m (£550m) a year the US was spending on counter-narcotics would be better used in supporting Afghan farmers,” reports the BBC. ” ‘It hasn’t hurt the Taleban one iota,” he said, “because whatever money they’re getting from the drugs trade, they get whatever they need whether we reduce the acreage or not.’ ” Mother Jones’s David Corn was present, and proved not entirely invulnerable to the legendary Holbrooke charm: Holbrooke is a wonderfully engaging character—an old-school power player. He schmoozes reporters, coming across as intelligent, crafty, and ...
Obama's Af/Pak Strategy And A Pony
Newshoggers.com —
... In fact, the Obama strategy is more like the blueprint for a plan than the plan itself. There are some encouraging ideas - like Holbrooke saying the entire war on opium in Afghanistan needs a rethink - but overall a blurry, undefined plan for doubling down, surging and "when they stand up" exits should shame all Obama supporters who spent so much time rightly castigating Bush administration white paper strategies for Iraq as being ill-defined "wishing for a pony". Even Bush's plans were more detailled than we've had out of the Obama administration so far. ...
“We’re going to have to rethink the drug problem”
HorsesAss.Org —
... that we’ve already created in Mexico, with terrorist groups reaping massive profits from an illegal trade that we can’t stop. I’m hoping that this article on newly appointed Ambassador Richard Holbrooke is a sign that our policy is going to finally deal with reality over there: ...
Is Holbrooke Off the (War on Drugs) Wagon?
David Corn —
... continued to talk to the reporters in the room. Prompted to address the opium trade's impact on the potential for success in Afghanistan, he called for "a complete rethink" of the war on drugs in Afghanistan and suggested that he was hardly gung-ho on the poppy eradication program there. So is Holbrooke off the (anti-drug) wagon? He did note that the review process had not been able to produce any consensus on this knotty matter. You can read my full account of Holbrooke's comments here. Holbrooke's remarks certainly deserve follow-up. ...
The War on the War on Drugs
Opinionator —
... enthused I’m no longer viewed as a lunatic trying to hook their kids on crack. My mother reports that Republican doctors at her workplace, guys who complain about taxes and have NRA stickers on their cars, are muttering about taxing and legalizing. The War on the War on Drugs has had its surges in the past, but without realizing any changes in policy. This time around it may achieve results. Even if Obama is not ready to embrace the idea, some in his administration are. Last Friday, David Corn asked Richard Holbrooke about the priority of drug fighting in Afghanistan. “We’re ...
Related Content
The Cost Of A COIN War In Afghanistan
newshoggers.com 3/19/2009 — By Steve Hynd
It's apparently a taboo subject - no-one wants to talk about how much a COIN war in Afghanistan will cost or even how long it will last. Conservatives simply don't want to "lose" and don't seem to care about the costs, while ...
The Ethics of Afghanistan
openleft.com 4/10/2009 — There are many ways to answer that question. However, the primary way the question should be approached is ethical: will our continued, escalated military action in Afghanistan (and Pakistan) prevent more human suffering than it causes?
As ...
Troop Surge in Afghanistan Means No Progressive Consensus
dailykos.com 2/21/2009 — President Barack Obama's Tuesday announcement that the U.S. will be adding 17,000 fresh troops to those already fighting in Afghanistan upended hopes among some progressives that the 60-day policy review he announced February 10 would be completed ...
More Troops for Afghanistan
attackerman.firedoglake.com 2/18/2009 — He promised to do so on the campaign trail, and now he's done it: President Barack Obama has approved a troop increase to Afghanistan. His just-released statement is below. Notice that the forces approved appears to be less than the 20,000-30,000 ...
McCain on Afghanistan at AEI
weeklystandard.com 2/25/2009 — Senator McCain is just now delivering a speech at AEI on the war in Afghanistan. Some highlights:
"Success is possible in Afghanistan. Afghans reject the Taliban. Just 4 percent of Afghans wish them to rule the country, and they rate the Taliban ...
Kissinger: COIN Won’t Work/McCain: CT Won’t Work
outsidethebeltway.com 2/27/2009 — Within the last couple of days both Sen. John McCain and former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger have offered contrasting strategies for Afghanistan. John McCain’s plan was explained in a speech before the American Enterprise Institute and ...
My Occupation's Known, but Not Why I Occupy
obsidianwings.blogs.com 3/23/2009 — by Eric Martin
In a recent post , I took issue with Andrew Exum's claim that counterinsurgency (COIN) practitioners are reluctant to endorse undertaking COIN-based missions - a skepticism that stems from their first hand knowledge of the enormous ...
Get Afghanistan Right
dailykos.com 1/13/2009 — An ad hoc group of bloggers has come together for the purpose of opposing a U.S.-led escalation in Afghanistan that is slated to double the number of American troops there. Organized by Alex Thurston at The Seminal and Robert Greenwald's ...
Afghanistan: There Must be Some Kind of Way out of Here
attackerman.firedoglake.com 3/28/2009 —
photo by fernando
On '60 Minutes' this Sunday, President Obama said "There’s got to be an exit strategy" for Afghanistan, but today he... didn't give one . What's the story with that? The chairpeople of the administration strategy ...
Out of Afghanistan
thenation.com 5/20/2009 — In my view, there are many good reasons to support the withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan. But Afghanistan is not Iraq and public opinion still largely supports Obama's escalation. (This is partly, I think, because there's so little media ...
Obama unveils new Afghan-Pak policy —
First Read 3/27/2009
From NBC's Athena Jones The future of Afghanistan is "inextricably linked" to the future of Pakistan, President Obama argued today as he announced a sweeping new policy toward Afghanistan that will include more troops for the country and more ...
The Senate Week Ahead —
First Read 3/27/2009
From NBC's Ken StricklandOn Wednesday, General David Petraeus returns to Capitol Hill to discuss the president's new Afghanistan-Pakistan strategy. He'll testify before the Senate Armed Services Committee in his role as the Centcom commander. Also ...