Submit a Story!
Ideologically-divided 5-4 Supreme Court reverses New Haven firefighters case.
Ideologically-divided 5-4 Supreme Court reverses New Haven firefighters case.
For 25 years, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has given employers broad discretion to reconsider a promotion test whose results favor one race over another. Judge Sonia Sotomayor followed this binding precedent when she rejected several firefighters’ claim of ...
Justices Reject Sotomayor Position 9-0 -- But Bigger Battles Loom
Justices Reject Sotomayor Position 9-0 -- But Bigger Battles Loom
ninthjustice.nationaljournal.com — The Supreme Court's predictable 5-4 vote to reverse the decision by Judge Sonia Sotomayor and two federal appeals court colleagues against 17 white (and one Hispanic) plaintiffs in the now-famous New Haven, Conn., firefighters decision does not by ... (more) Justices Reject Sotomayor Position 9-0 -- But Bigger ...
Supreme Court Reverses Sotomayor
legalinsurrection.blogspot.com — In a 5-4 ruling authored by Justice Anthony Kennedy, the U.S. Supreme Court has reversed the ruling by Supreme Court Nominee Sonia Sotomayor and two other Court of Appeals judges in the case of Ricci v. DeStefano . [Full opinion and analysis below] ... (more) Supreme Court Reverses Sotomayor
Racism rejected: SCOTUS reverses Sotomayor in firefighters case
Racism rejected: SCOTUS reverses Sotomayor in firefighters case
michellemalkin.com — President Obama applauds the decision as a victory for equality under the law. [...] Read the rest » (more) Racism rejected: SCOTUS reverses Sotomayor in ...
Comments
Blog Reactions

The Ricci Case
Matthew Yglesias — ... As expected, the Supreme Court handed down a 5-4 decision reversing the Second Circuit’s decision on the Ricci firefighter case. As Ian Millhiser explains: ...

Supreme Court: States Have The Right To Investigate National Banks For Lending Discrimination
Wonk Room — ... Though the Supreme Court case garnering the most headlines today will be the Ricci v. DeStefano employment discrimination case, a second decision came down with important implications for the future of financial regulation. In a ...

Conservatives Attack Sotomayor For Not Having A Crystal Ball
Wonk Room — ... The basis of this claim is the fact that both Justice Kennedy’s majority opinion and Justice Ginsburg’s dissent created new legal standards which are different than the twenty-five year old rule Sotomayor was required to follow in Ricci.  Under the Second Circuit’s 1984 decision in ...

A Storm’s Coming On Campaign Finance
Wonk Room — ... Yesterday’s high-profile decision in the Ricci firefighters case obscures another, equally important development which could usher in a new era of corporate money in politics.  Traditionally, the Supreme Court decides every single case it heard during a particular term before adjourning for the summer recess.  This Term, however, the Court announced that it will leave one case, a campaign finance case called ...

With Ricci, Court Redefines Judicial Activism
Firedoglake — ... that the Court was unanimous in its decision -- no idea how 5-4 with a concurrence from Alito is "unanimous," but then, I'm not Stuart Taylor trying to do whatever it is that he does when he gets a burr in his shorts (or helping Wendy Long advance her whinery, whatever comes first). It's clearly the "new new" in right wing talking points, because Sen. Cornyn's been mouthing it, too. ...

Related: ct race and promotion case
ABC Hits Reverse Discrimination Case From Left; CBS Skips It EntirelyNewsBusters.org - Exposing Liberal Media Bias
Following up on Monday’s Supreme Court ruling in favor of New Haven firefighters who were denied promotion after no black applicants passed a written exam, ABC’s Bob Woodruff on Tuesday’s Good Morning America approached the decision from a liberal perspective, wondering if “the ruling really ...