Submit a Story!
topics:

In Which I Disagree With Megan McArdle Some More
by hilzoy Megan McCardle has a rather peculiar response to my last post : "Listening to the debates about abortion, it seems to me that really broad swathes of the pro-choice movement seem to genuinely not understand that this is a debate about personhood, which is why you get moronic ...
In Which I Disagree With Megan McArdle
obsidianwings.blogs.com — by hilzoy Earlier, I argued that we ought to take steps to assure that late-term abortions are... available to people who need them, and that one reason to do so was to make it clear that terrorism does not pay. In response, Megan McArdle writes :  ... (more) In Which I Disagree With Megan McArdle
MEGAN MCARDLE: Sotomayor and the Problem of Affirmative Action….
pajamasmedia.com — MEGAN MCARDLE: Sotomayor and the Problem of Affirmative Action.... (more) MEGAN MCARDLE: Sotomayor and the Problem of Affirmative ...
Iraq: Victory or defeat?
pajamasmedia.com — We are in trouble in Iraq. The Bush victory was a fraud. That, in short is the... judgment of Thomas Ricks writing in the Foreign Policy Review. His essential claims are that the turnaround in Iraq began when US Commanders began listening to foreign and ... (more) Iraq: Victory or defeat?
Comments
Blog Reactions

One More Post on Abortion
Megan McArdle — Hilzoy responds: (a) We have a system for resolving political disputes in this country. We elect people, and those people make laws. When those laws are within the limits set by the Constitution, they are binding. When not, a court can strike them down. When we ...

A Question Of Legitimacy
The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan — Megan and Hilzoy have locked horns over abortion. Megan: My argument is that abortion, like slavery, is becoming in this country an issue upon which people have no reasonable political recourse.  I'll go further, and say that the process by which 7 judges enforced their consciences on the American public was itself borderline illegitimate; it was first, not in their proper job description, and second, a bad way to run a government. Hilzoy: If anyone who believes the government had adopted a policy that would lead to the killing of ...

links for 2009-06-03
J. Bradford DeLong's Grasping Reality with All Eight Tentacles — ... Felix Salmon: Understanding Taleb David Beckworth: GDI vs. GDP Hilzoy: In Which I Disagree With Megan McArdle Some More ...

Nice Reproductive Freedom You've Got There, Shame If Something Would Happen To It
Lawyers, Guns and Money — Given that many people have already critiqued the latest Douthat nonsense on abortion (see also here), for some variety I thought I'd address similar arguments made recently by Megan McArdle. From her response to Hilzoy: My argument is that abortion, like slavery, is becoming in this country an issue upon which people have no reasonable political recourse. I'll go further, and say that the process by which 7 judges enforced their consciences on the American public was itself borderline illegitimate; it was first, not in their proper job ...

Mike's Blog Round Up
Crooks and Liars — Alicublog: Six sizzling excerpts from Going Rogue. You betcha. Fafblog: The Muslims are due on Maple Street. driftglass: The jolly banksters. The Hunting of the Snark: Being unable to choose to have an abortion is pro-choice?!? The Satirical Political Report: Hannity's "apology." Guest post by Batocchio. Send tips to batocchio9 AT yahoo dot com ...

Related: hilzoy abortion
A Really Long Post About Abortion and Reasoning By Historical Analogy That is Going to Make Virtually All of My Readers Very Angry At Me
meganmcardle.theatlantic.com 6/2/2009 — I tried to respond to Publius and Hilzoy at their place, but the comments system wouldn't let me.  So I'll have to carry the debate on here. Why the analogy to slavery, or Hitler?  It's inflammatory, and rarely advances the debate.  ...