Submit a Story!
Is Obama relying too much on tax cuts?
I don't know yet. But news reports this morning certainly raise questions. Let's lay out the basics here. Other things equal, public investment is a much better way to provide economic stimulus than tax cuts, for two reasons. First, if the government spends money, that money is spent, helping ...
Obama Plan Includes $300 Billion in Tax Cuts
Obama Plan Includes $300 Billion in Tax Cuts
nytimes.com — Tax cuts for workers and businesses are nods to critics worried that the economic recovery program has been too focused on government spending, advisers said. > (more) Obama Plan Includes $300 Billion in Tax Cuts
Obama plans to unveil big tax cuts
politico.com — President-elect Obama plans to propose huge tax cuts for businesses and middle-class workers that will total about 40 percent of the package. (more) Obama plans to unveil big tax cuts
Should We Devote 40% of the Stimulus to Tax Cuts?
Should We Devote 40% of the Stimulus to Tax Cuts?
ourfuture.org — The Wall Street Journal reports this morning that President-elect Barack Obama is planning to devote roughly 40 percent of any new economic stimulus package to tax cuts. Arguing for the idea in the face of failed Bush tax cuts over the last eight ... (more) Should We Devote 40% of the Stimulus to Tax Cuts?

Blog Reactions

Corrente:  Insane Republicans

AMERICAblog News| A great nation deserves the truth:  Krugman expressing doubts about Obama massive tax cut plan

The Agonist - thoughtful, global, timely:  Three Hundred Billion In Tax-Cuts?

Comments
Blog Reactions

Insane Republicans
Corrente — ... is sucking up to insane people, since it's going to be 40% tax cuts, which provide less stimulus than spending. But here's the insane part: ...

Krugman expressing doubts about Obama massive tax cut plan
AMERICAblog News| A great nation deserves the truthPaul Krugman weighs in: [T]here’s a reasonable economic case for including a significant amount of tax cuts in the package, mainly in year one. But the numbers being reported — 40 percent of the whole, two-year plan — sound high. And all the news reports say that the high tax-cut share is intended to assuage Republicans; what this presumably means is that this was the message the off-the-record Obamanauts were told to convey. And that’s bad news. Look, Republicans are not going to come on board. Make 40% of the package tax cuts, ...

Three Hundred Billion In Tax-Cuts?
The Agonist - thoughtful, global, timely — ... tends to be met with fewer objections than plans for public investment “which, because they are not wholly wasteful, tend to be judged on strict ‘business’ principles.” What gets lost in such discussions is the key argument for economic stimulus — namely, that under current conditions, a surge in public spending would employ Americans who would otherwise be unemployed and money that would otherwise be sitting idle, and put both to work producing something useful. Or this: [P]ublic investment offers more bang for the buck. Second, public ...

Krugman: Obama Relying Too Much On Tax Cuts?
Politics on HuffingtonPost.com — ... In a blog post, economist Paul Krugman worries that President-elect Barack Obama is relying too much on tax cuts in his stimulus plan in an effort to appease Republicans. ...

Krugman: Obama Relying Too Much On Tax Cuts?
The Huffington Post | Full News Feed — ... In a blog post, economist Paul Krugman worries that President-elect Barack Obama is relying too much on tax cuts in his stimulus plan in an effort to appease Republicans. ...

Is Obama Overdoing the Tax Cuts?
The Stump — Today's papers bring word that Obama wants to devote up to 40 percent of the stimulus plan to tax cuts, which seems partly intended to attract Republican support. For what it's worth, I'm not as worried about the idea as Josh Marshall and Paul Krugman, but some of the specifics do make me queasy. Krugman writes that: Other things equal, public investment is a much better way to provide economic stimulus than tax cuts, for two reasons. First, if the government spends money, ...

Republian Idealogues Happy With Tax Cuts, But How About The Poor?
Firedoglake — ... Krugman: Look, Republicans are not going to come on board. Make 40% of the package tax cuts, they’ll demand 100%. Then they’ll start the thing about how you can’t cut taxes on people who don’t pay taxes (with only income taxes counting, of ...

News Flash: Obama to Fulfill Campaign Promises!
Angry Bear — Tom Bozzo is amazed at the reaction of leading figures in the left blogiverse to the W$J's "news" that there will be tax cuts as part of the stimulus. See Aravosis, Digby, Krugman, Marshall. Can we cancel the circular firing squad? As far as I can tell from the Journal's reporting, the main tax elements are largely indistinguishable from what Obama was promoting in the fall. Here, for instance, is a snippet of the third debate: [Bob Schieffer:] Senator Obama, you proposed $60 billion in tax cuts for middle- income ...

Obama Courts Conservatives With Large Tax Cuts In Proposed Stimulus Plan
Wonk Room — ... ” comes from spending increases (particularly infrastructure investment, extending unemployment benefits, and temporarily increased funding for food stamps), while tax cuts are much less effective. Furthermore, as Paul Krugman noted, “public investment leaves something of value behind when the stimulus is over” whereas tax cuts do not. ...

Does Obama Have What It Takes To Rescue America From The Bush Economic Miracle?
DownWithTyranny! — ... So far Obama has shown himself to be a wimpy compromiser who is absolutely unwilling to stand his ground on anything. The Republicans see that and they certainly plan to take advantage of it-- in the most brazen partisan fashion-- and slow down and shred his plans for an adequate stimulus package. He's offering them a mammoth tax cut program, all ...

Hullabaloo — ... just for the sake of doing so. Not only is it unlikely, it will end up really eroding Obama's ability to draw on popular support to govern. Update: from digby --- I just wanted to intrude on dday's post to encourage you all to read the article to which he links called "Can Partisanship Save Citizenship" by Henry Farrell. It is very illuminating. . ...I want to further intrude on my own post to link to Krugman's view, via his blog, on the tax cut rumblings.

Remainders: Biden on the loose
Ben Smith's Blog — ... on Obama's having corrupt allies. A judge orders the release of Blago tapes. The Secretary of the Senate rejected his credentials. Mitch Stewart and Jeremy Bird will run Obama for America and, with Jen O'Malley, likely play key roles in the 2012 reelect. Psychology Today psychologizes Caroline's "you know." She's losing ground in a new poll. Rudy keeps his name in the mix in New York. Krugman doesn't like all the tax cuts in the stimulus. Ami Eden weighs in against ...

Examining the stimulus package
Daily Kos — ... , and Paul Krugman take a look at the emerging details surrounding President-elect Obama's stimulus package, particularly the roughly $300 billion in proposed tax cuts. ...

Would somebody please remind Barack Obama that he won?
Brilliant at Breakfast — ... himself that the kind of politics the Republicans play in Washington is a far cry from what they're able to get away with in predominantly Democratic Chicago, or if he just plain is a Republican in disguise, it's looking more every day like his idea of bipartisanship is less oriented towards persuasion and more the Harry Reid style of letting them take his lunch money and thanking them for doing it. Because the Obama Economic Plan is starting to look awfully Republican to me -- and to Paul Krugman: Let’s lay out the basics here. Other things equal, public ...

Obama's clever fiscal stimulus strategy
The Next Right — Barack Obama appears to be making significant overtures to cultivate Republican support for his fiscal stimulus plan with massive tax cuts (albeit short-term tax shifts rather than structural changes or actual cuts).  The Leftroots (and Paul Krugman) are fairly upset about this.  Kevin Drum says this attempt to win bipartisan support (rather than just the few Republican votes he absolutely needs to secure passage) is a bad idea, because Obama is making concessions he doesn't have to make and diluting ...

How Obama's Tax Cut Gambit Is Shrewder Than You Think
The Stump — ... , which is powerful on its own, and Obama's denial of this motive.) In response to which, people like Paul Krugman argue that: ...

It's time to leave economic recovery to the grownups, and have the wingnuts obstructionists shut the hell up
DownWithTyranny! — ... In a Monday blog post called "Is Obama relying too much on tax cuts?," Paul Krugman allowed that there is a case to be made for including tax cuts in the stimulus package: ...

Earmarks and the Stimulus Bill
The Corner on National Review Online — ... on marginal projects. Paul Krugman, the foremost intellectual defender of the approach embodied in the bill, has expressed the worry only that there aren't enough things to spend all the stimulus money on. As he said on "This Week" a couple of weeks ago: "My problem is that the actual constraint is not going to be political will. No. The actual constraint is going to be finding enough stuff to spend on." This same worry is why he's favorable to some tax cuts as part of the bill in this post . Remember, the theory behind the bill is that in current circumstances pretty much any ...

Krugman: Obama's Stimulus Doesn't Go Far Enough
Politics on HuffingtonPost.com — ... Paul Krugman has already criticized President-elect Barack Obama for appearing to rely too much on tax cuts in his economic plan. Now he's adding a more general concern that the plan ...

Krugman: Obama's Stimulus Doesn't Go Far Enough
The Huffington Post | Full News Feed — ... Paul Krugman has already criticized President-elect Barack Obama for appearing to rely too much on tax cuts in his economic plan. Now he's adding a more general concern that the plan ...

Kick it Root Down
Obsidian Wings — ... There is room to criticize Obama's proposed stimulus plan: some could plausibly argue that certain of the tax cuts are less than ideal in terms of delivering stimulus and/or job growth.  ...

Kick it Root Down
Newshoggers.com — ... There is room to criticize Obama's proposed stimulus plan: some could plausibly argue that certain of the tax cuts are less than ideal in terms of delivering stimulus and/or job growth.  ...

1/13: Oh, Guantanamo
Blogometer — ... of tax cuts that Krugman and other economists think will be ineffective stimulus measures in order to try to attract additional GOP support. [...] As I have ...

So Every House Republican Voted Against Stimulus. What Do We Learn?
MoJo Blog Posts: mojo — ... . Obama, who had hoped for a widely supported bill, got stonewalled despite doing three things: (1) fashioning roughly 1/3 of the package out of tax cuts, which the GOP loves; (2) going to the House Republican caucus and asking for their input; and (3) pulling provisions from the bill that Republicans didn't like ( ...

Insane Right-Wing Tax Cut Fetish
Comments from Left Field — ... And most recently, in his NYT column dated January 5, 2009, Krugman questions Pres. Obama’s over-reliance on tax cuts in the stimulus package (the one that just passed in the House without a single Republican vote): ...

Tentative Stimulus Deal Confirms Krugman’s Law
Suburban Guerrilla — ... by bringing a knife to a gun fight with Congressional Republicans, it’s hard to disagree with New York Times columnist Paul Krugman’s January 5th prediction of what would come to pass. Call it Krugman’s Law: ...

Open Thread for Night Owls, Early Birds & Expats
Daily Kos — ... While many of my liberal allies disagree with my assessment that President Obama got rolled by bringing a knife to a gun fight with Congressional Republicans, it's hard to disagree with New York Times columnist Paul Krugman's January 5th prediction of what would come to pass. Call it Krugman's Law: ...

Gov. Perdue: States Shouldn’t Rely On Supply-Side Economics During Recession
Think Progress — ... Opportunity, and Business Success Act of 2009,” a businesss tax cut-centered bill that would cost $340 million a year in lost revenue. True to conservative form, the legislation cuts the state capital gains tax in half. The bill would also be a “substantial tax increase on most low- and middleincome Georgians,” notes the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy Indeed, supply-side tax cuts tilted towards big business and the wealthy are anti-stimulative during a deep recession, and do not lead to appreciable gains in revenue for ...

Having Ignored Krugman’s Law, Obama Should Heed Cheney’s Law
The Moderate Voice — Both laws are essentially the same — the only difference being that one is stated as a warning, the other as a credo: On January 5th, the Nobel prize-winning New York Times columnist Paul Krugman predicted what would come to pass in an early statement of Krugman’s Law. For all of his goodwill, White House meetings, compromises and lofty rhetoric, the new President would - and did - get the back of the hand from Republicans: “Look, Republicans are not going to ...

Related Content
Obama Shouldn't Cave to the Right on Tax Cuts
realclearpolitics.com 1/8/2009 — The lesson of the Bush era is that relying on tax cuts as the centerpiece -- often the only piece -- of economic policy is just plain bad policy.
Obama won't compromise on tax cuts
politico.com 1/27/2009 — Obama has told House Republicans he will not compromise any further on tax cuts in the economic stimulus.
Tax Cuts Aren't The Solution
workinglife.org 1/7/2009 — Well, welcome back to all who have been kicking back for the past few days, including yours truly. This year is going to be quite interesting--and, unfortunately, not a happy one as far as the economy goes, or so I'm guessing. I'm not going to ...
$300 Billion in Tax Cuts?
talkingpointsmemo.com 1/5/2009 — I'm going to dig more into the details on this tomorrow. But this is starting to sound like a pretty big chunk of the stimulus bill is aimed at garnering GOP support. I really hope we're not putting the cart before the horse here. And these ...
Obama to GOP: No compromise on more tax cuts
twincities.com 1/27/2009 — President Barack Obama rolled into the Capitol with a clear message for Republicans this afternoon: He's happy to talk, but he's not compromising on tax cuts. Obama was ready for the House Republicans to pounce, telling them: "Feel free to whack me ...
Obama's "Tax Cuts"
minx.cc 10/14/2008 — During the debate liveblogs, a phrase I find myself typing often is "TAX CREDITS ARE NOT TAX CUTS." It's usually in response to Barack Obama's promise to "cut taxes for 95% of Americans," a promise that as of now, has...
More Voters Than Ever Say Tax Cuts Help the Economy
rasmussenreports.com 3/27/2009 — Democrats in the Senate are talking of cutting back President Obama's pledge of tax cuts for most Americans in the face of record deficits. But 63% of U.S. voters now say tax cuts would help the economy, according to a new Rasmussen Reports national ...
Democrats criticize Obama's proposed tax cuts (AP)
news.yahoo.com 1/9/2009 — AP - President-elect Barack Obama's proposed tax cuts ran into opposition Thursday from senators in his own party who said they wouldn't do much to stimulate the economy or create jobs. Senators from both parties agreed that Congress should do ...
NYT: Obama plan includes $300 billion in tax cuts
msnbc.msn.com 1/5/2009 — President-elect Barack Obama plans to include about $300 billion in tax cuts for workers and businesses in his economic recovery program, as his team seeks to win over Congressional skeptics.
Stiglitz: Just Say No to Tax Cuts
economistsview.typepad.com 1/16/2009 — Joseph Stiglitz on the tax cuts versus spending question: Do not squander America’s stimulus on tax cuts, by Joseph Stiglitz, Commentary, Financial Times : As news of the US economy worsens, worries about whether a stimulus could restart the economy ...
Obama, Congress leaders to meet on economymsnbc.com: Politics 1/5/2009
The President-elect is heading to Capitol Hill to push for quick action on a broad economic stimulus package that congressional leaders are saying won't be ready until mid-February at the earliest.
Obama's girls enroll for classes at private schoolmsnbc.com: Politics 1/5/2009
First things first: President-elect Barack Obama's two daughters have checked into their new school in Washington.
Obama adds 'Neighborhood Ball' to festivities (AP)Yahoo! News: Politics News 1/5/2009
AP - President-elect Barack Obama is adding a "Neighborhood Ball" to the list of inaugural parties planned just over two weeks from now.
CNNMoney.com: Obama readies push on recovery planCNN Political Ticker 1/5/2009
NEW YORK (CNNMoney.com) — President-elect Barack Obama was set Monday to begin the push for a massive package of tax cuts and spending proposals aimed at reviving an economy mired in recession. Obama will meet with top legislators from both ...
Obama Seeks Middle Ground With Republicans on Economic PackageWSJ.com: Washington Wire 1/5/2009
Naftali Bendavid reports on Congress. President-elect Barack Obama , coming to Capitol Hill today for the first time since his election, went out of his way to reach out to Republicans, and they seemed to respond in kind. After separate ...