Submit a Story!
Kristol Makes His Fourth Factual Error In His New York Times Column
Kristol Makes His Fourth Factual Error In His New York Times Column
Today in the New York print edition of the New York Times, columnist Bill Kristol attacks allegations that Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) may not have been in the “cone of silence” during Saturday’s Saddleback Civil Forum: NBC’s Andrea Mitchell reported on “Meet the Press” that “the Obama people must feel that he didn’t do quite as well as they might have wanted to in that ...
Comments
Blog Reactions

Bill Kristol, the gift that keeps on giving
Political Animal — ... Every writer makes mistakes; I’ve made plenty myself. But Kristol’s writing is pedestrian and predictable; the Times has editors and fact-checkers; and he’s only been on the job since January. And how many times has the Times been forced to run corrections relating to Kristol’s sloppiness? Based on a count from Amanda at TP, we’ve seen three in the last eight months, and today’s error would be #4. (If you want to get picky about it, one of Amanda’s examples included two separate factual errors in the same column, which would make ...

Number Four
Matthew Yglesias — ... Amanda Terkel notes the fourth time The New York Times has needed to make a material correction to Bill Kristol’s column since it was launched in January. Is this seriously the best person the NYT could find to fill that slot? I bet it’s not difficult to identify people willing to take on the challenge of the country’s most prestigious op-ed page page. ...

Putting the rat in erratum
Firedoglake — ... But by far my favorite aspect of Kristol's column -- other than the forthcoming correction -- is the never ending series of McCain VP predictions. ...

Kristol's meth
Rising Hegemon — ... But by far my favorite aspect of Kristol's column -- other than the forthcoming correction -- is the never ending series of McCain VP predictions. ...

Kristol clear
Political Animal — ... ticket would be as conservative as any traditional Republican pairing, but voters might be fooled into thinking otherwise . That, at its core, is Kristol's message to the McCain campaign: pick Lieberman, run to the right, and con the public into thinking the ticket is something unique and different. How painfully cynical, and yet, strangely predictable, given the source. Post Script : I should add, by the way, that this makes one column in a row in which Kristol did not publish any obvious factual errors that required printed corrections. Keep up the sterling work, Bill.— ...

Ambivalent
Firedoglake — ... Oh, Bill Kristol, he's ever so busy, almost as much as his New York Times fact-checker. His contract is nearly up with the Times, ...

"You don't have the Prestige!"
Rising Hegemon — ... Oh, Bill Kristol, he's ever so busy, almost as much as his New York Times fact-checker. His contract is nearly up with the Times, ...

?Kristol Ball? Breaks: Stevens Will ?Hang On In Alaska,? McCain Will Conquer The ?Path To The Presidency?
The Hollywood Liberal — ... record during this campaign season. Perhaps that’s because the man behind it is still trying to perfect a more elementary skill: fact-checking . Transcript: ...

Kristol leaves the Times
Political Animal — ... one-year contract with the paper of record would get an extension, and today, we get our answer: he's done. Whether the Times showed him the door or Kristol quit is unclear, but the result is the same. It's hard to overstate what an embarrassment this was from the start. Not only was Kristol's writing pedestrian and predictable, but he had an unfortunate habit of making obvious factual mistakes, which necessitated frequent corrections. Indeed, at last count, Kristol prompted four corrections in one year -- though, if you want to get picky about it, one of the four included ...

Related Content
Mitchell Also Circulated Obama's Conspiracy Theory Over Cancelled Troop Visit
newsbusters.org 8/18/2008 — Andrea Mitchell's floating of the Obama-camp accusation that John McCain cheated by overhearing Obama's responses at the Saddleback forum, as NewsBuster D.S. Hube reported , isn't the first time the NBC correspondent has made herself the ...
Cone of Silence
thismodernworld.com 8/18/2008 — Bill Kristol, in the print edition of this morning’s New York Times: NBC’s Andrea Mitchell reported on “Meet the Press” that “the Obama people must feel that he didn’t do quite as well as they might have wanted to in that context. … What ...
Did McCain's Campaign Just Confirm Andrea Mitchell's Reporting?
fivethirtyeight.com 8/18/2008 — The Politico has the text of a vitriolic letter in which the McCain campaign takes Andrea Mitchell and NBC to task for "giving voice to unsubstantiated, partisan claims in order to undercut John McCain". However, rather than being refuted, Mitchell's ...
McCain Campaign Protests to NBC Over Mitchell's Cheating Claim
newsbusters.org 8/18/2008 — The McCain campaign isn't taking Andrea Mitchell's cheating claim made on Sunday's "Meet the Press" lying down. Politico reported moments ago that campaign manager Rick Davis has sent a strongly-worded letter to Steve Capus, president of ...
How do we know John McCain Did Best at Saddleback? The Media is Pushing the "McCain Cheated" Theory for Obama
redstate.com 8/18/2008 — Following up on Moe's post. And yes, I do question Obama's commitment to his faith. " McCain did well because he understands the issues close to the hearts of the people at Saddleback. Obama did poorly because he does not understand those ...
McCain: Obama tried to legislate Iraqi failure (AP)Yahoo! News: Politics News 8/18/2008
AP - John McCain told fellow veterans on Monday that his Democratic rival Barack Obama tried to legislate failure in Iraq and has refused to admit he erred when opposing the military increase there last year.
Obama Fundraisers in San Francisco Draw $7.8 MillionFOXNews.com 8/18/2008
SAN FRANCISCO — Barack Obama raked $7.8 million Sunday at three separate fundraisers in San Francisco, telling a VIP dinner crowd — many of whom paid $28,500 to attend — that he would win the presidency in November but to expect a ...
McCain: Obama Tried to Legislate Failure in IraqFOXNews.com 8/18/2008
ORLANDO, Fla. — John McCain told fellow veterans on Monday that his Democratic rival Barack Obama tried to legislate failure in Iraq and has refused to admit he erred when opposing the military increase there last year. McCain said Obama ...
McCain hits Obama on 'failure of judgement'CNN Political Ticker 8/18/2008
(CNN) — John McCain told a veterans group Monday that Barack Obama cares more about politics than winning the war in Iraq. “With less than three months to go before the election, a lot of people are still trying to square Senator Obama’s varying ...
McCain: Obama tried to legislate Iraqi failuremsnbc.com: Politics 8/18/2008
The GOP presidential hopeful  told fellow veterans on Monday his Democratic rival Barack Obama tried to legislate failure in Iraq and has refused to admit he erred when opposing the military increase there.