Submit a Story!
McCain v. Obama: Round 1
McCain v. Obama: Round 1
There were no knockout blows in this debate, but McCain won on points--a surprise for people like me who expected a crushing performance from the much more silver-tongued Barack Obama. That didn't happen tonight. Instead, Obama seemed at times to wither against McCain. "I agree with John" ...
Comments
Blog Reactions

"John Was Right"
Obsidian Wings — ... by hilzoy Last night, the fact that Obama said that McCain was right on several occasions caused consternation among some liberals, and great rejoicing on the right. I didn't agree. It would have been one thing had Obama not also been willing to say, forcefully, that he thought McCain was wrong. But he was, and usually his acknowledgement that McCain was right on some point was the preface to an explanation of why he was wrong on another. In that context, the fact that Obama was willing to acknowledge those points where he agreed with ...

"John Was Right"
Political Animal — "John Was Right" Last night, the fact that Obama said that McCain was right on several occasions caused consternation among some liberals, and great rejoicing on the right. I didn't agree. It would have been one thing had Obama not also been willing to say, forcefully, that he thought McCain was wrong. But he was, and usually his acknowledgement that McCain was right on some point was the preface to an explanation of why he was wrong on another. In that context, the fact that Obama was willing to acknowledge those points where he agreed with McCain struck me ...

Let’s Not Get So Upset About “John Is Right”
Comments from Left Field — I’m with Hilzoy on this one (my emphasis immediately below and in quote from Pat Lang): Last night, the fact that Obama said that McCain was right on several occasions caused consternation among some liberals, and great rejoicing on the right. I didn’t agree. It would have been one thing had Obama not also been willing to say, forcefully, that he thought McCain was wrong. But he was, and usually his acknowledgement that McCain was right on some point was the preface to an explanation of why he was ...

9/29: Friday Night Lights
Blogometer — September 29, 2008 9/29: Friday Night Lights Conservative bloggers almost unanimously proclaimed John McCain the winner of Friday night's debate. Righty bloggers praised McCain's energy, aggressiveness, and knowledge of foreign policy. They also argued that Barack Obama deferred to McCain on too many issues, as evidenced by his repeated use of phrases such as "John is right" or "I agree with John" . Paul Mirengoff echoes many conservative bloggers when he writes: "McCain was the teacher; Obama was the promising but somewhat disappointing student." Most ...

Related Content
Tom Shales - McCain's High Horse Meets Obama's High-Mindedness
washingtonpost.com 9/27/2008 — Comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. ...
Round 1 in debates goes to Obama, poll says
cnn.com 9/27/2008 — Most debate watchers agreed both McCain and Obama would be able to handle the job of president if elected.
Points About the Points
corner.nationalreview.com 9/27/2008 — Many, many readers have written that my quick points on the debate depressed them -- why did they have to be taken down, after being so up after McCain's impressive performance? No one need be depressed: McCain did very well. He held up our end, as I ...
Mark Shields: "Obama More Than Held His Own"
openleft.com 9/27/2008 — I spent the debate reading twitter, on IM, and going around the blogs and traditional media sites.  In the background was Obama and McCain chattering, and occasionally I looked up and saw the TV.  So no cone of silence, but no real focus ...
After the Oxford debate...
turcopolier.typepad.com 9/27/2008 — Having watched it, I would say that Obama wins on points as a gentleman and McCain loses on coming across as a victim of coaching by brutes like Rick Davis et al. There will be those, like the oaf Chris...
Kissinger defends McCain on Iranian relationsCNN Political Ticker 9/27/2008
Former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger defended McCain's stance on Irania relations Friday night. (CNN)—Former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger defended Sen. John McCain Friday night in his attack against Sen. Barack Obama for being ...
2 quick polls give Obama edge in debate (AP)Yahoo! News: Politics News 9/27/2008
AP - A pair of one-night polls gave Barack Obama a clear edge over John McCain in their first presidential debate.
McCain making calls on bailout latestCNN Political Ticker 9/27/2008
(CNN)– John McCain is at his national campaign headquarters in Arlington, Virginia at this hour. His campaign tells us he's meeting with advisers regarding the proposed $700 billion federal bailout and the latest negotiations and developments on ...
Snapshot Polls Give Obama Edge Over McCain in DebateFOXNews.com 9/27/2008
WASHINGTON — A pair of one-night polls gave Barack Obama a clear edge over John McCain in their first presidential debate. Fifty-one percent said Obama, the Democrat, did a better job in Friday night’s faceoff while 38 percent preferred ...
McCain, Obama fight for title of 'most qualified'CNN Political Ticker 9/27/2008
Sens. McCain and Obama went head to head Friday night in their first presidential debate. WASHINGTON (CNN) — In their first head-to-head debate, Sen. John McCain criticized Sen. Barack Obama as a candidate who "doesn't understand" the key ...