Submit a Story!
More on the Cone of Not-So-Silence
Regarding the revelation that Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., was not in a "cone of silence" after all while Sen. Barack Obama, D-Illinois, answered questions from Pastor Rick Warren, a couple points…. 1) The McCain campaign's vitriol against NBC's Andrea Mitchell...
Comments
Blog Reactions

Fake "Cone of silence" controvery grows - McCain refusing to directly answer the questaion. More from ABC
AMERICAblog News| A great nation deserves the truth — Jake Tapper at ABC, along with Ben Smith at Politico, has been some of the few journalists willing to ask obvious questions that the corporate media so often don't ask. Tapper is on the trail of the phony "cone of silence" from yesterday's religious forum, and the McCain campaign is looking increasingly shifty. Here's what Jake has to report: ...

Don't Look Now But Your Insanity Is Showing
Ace of Spades HQ — ... is about an issue of even moderate importance. Who really cares what McCain's captors did? No one at all. In other words, it doesn't matter what McCain's story might have been. The Left would have found some way to call him a liar. Second, the cone of silence SCANDAL. That is all caps because judging by the amount of attention this story has been given in the legacy media (in addition to Lefty blogs), this is a Really. Big. DEAL. ABC's Jake Tapper, for example, has stumbled onto a particularly unpersuasive line of attack . Y'see, even though the McCain campaign has said that ...

McCain cheated on 'cone of silence'
Newshoggers.com — ... The denials have been somewhat nuanced. McCain's team hasn't flatly denied that no one in contact with McCain accessed the program while he was in enroute, although another McCain spokesman said they have no to reason to lie. But as Jake Tapper points out, obviously they every reason to do so. And as I added in a ...

Some Thoughts on the “Holier than Thou” Forum at Saddleback & A Suggestion for Future Forums
The Moderate Voice — ... ” or whether it was all fair and balanced or only as fair and balanced as Fox News. I think the whole discussion—given that it was presented by a religious moderator ...

Cone-of-Silence-Gate
Patterico's Pontifications — [Guest post by DRJ] I’m somewhat surprised the “McCain cheated at Saddleback” story is gaining traction but it seems to be with the mainstream media. ABC News’ Political Punch blog is now calling it Cone-of-Silence-Gate, although that may be tongue-in-cheek, and has already run two stories on the topic (here and here). Ironically, it now turns out that both candidates were told the general topics of Warren’s questions in advance and were given the following 2 questions in advance: What is ...

The Saddleback Forum *Unofficial* Transcript
Patterico's Pontifications — ... According to ABC News, Rick Warren’s spokesman, the McCain campaign, and other sources indicate John McCain arrived at the Forum at 5:20-5:30 PM PST. Rick Warren would have been about 1/3 to 1/2 of the way through his Q&A session with Barack Obama. Here’s a ...

Related: andrea mitchell cone of silence video youtube, mitchell, youtube and "cone of silence"
The NYT's Most Anti-McCain, Misleading Headline of the Week
newsbusters.org 8/18/2008 — Many of you are aware of the kerfuffle surrounding the "cone of silence" complaint being ginned up by the Obama campaign after the recent Saddleback Civil Forum on the Presidency on Saturday, August 16. The claim made by Obama and his willing ...
Cone of Silence
thismodernworld.com 8/18/2008 — Bill Kristol, in the print edition of this morning’s New York Times: NBC’s Andrea Mitchell reported on “Meet the Press” that “the Obama people must feel that he didn’t do quite as well as they might have wanted to in that context. … What ...
Kristol Makes His Fourth Factual Error In His New York Times Column
thinkprogress.org 8/18/2008 — Today in the New York print edition of the New York Times, columnist Bill Kristol attacks allegations that Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) may not have been in the “cone of silence” during Saturday’s Saddleback Civil Forum: NBC’s Andrea ...
McCain, Obama, and the "Cone of Silence"
corner.nationalreview.com 8/18/2008 — I've been looking into all this buzz that McCain somehow cheated -- that he wasn't in a 'cone of silence' -- during Barack Obama's half of the Saddleback summit Saturday night. The talk got started on 'Meet the Press' yesterday, when Andrea Mitchell ...
John McCain’s Cross In the Dirt: Faith Of Someone Else’s Father
firedoglake.com 8/18/2008 — John McCain hath decided he would rather spend the media cycle talking about the Cone of Silence , and thus Andrea Mitchell getteth hauled before the brass by Rick Davis today. But the more interesting McCain story du jour comes regards a ...
Eric Schmeltzer: Senator John Complain
huffingtonpost.com 8/18/2008 — Wow. So, Senator McCain goes on national television and lies to a pastor , pretending that he was in a "cone of silence" holding room during the Saddleback Forum where he couldn't hear the questions that he would be asked that were also being ...
Did Mitchell Get 'McCain Cheated' at Saddleback from Daily Kos?
newsbusters.org 8/18/2008 — As my colleague D.S. Hube reported , Andrea Mitchell on Sunday's "Meet the Press" suggested the Obama campaign felt John McCain " may not have been in the cone of silence " during Saturday's Saddleback Civil Forum, "and may ...
NYT Backs Up NBC: McCain Was Not In "Cone Of Silence" Before Saddleback
huffingtonpost.com 8/18/2008 — Last night, John McCain 's campaign manager Rick Davis sent a strongly-worded letter to NBC News president Steve Capus , complaining about "unsubstantiated, partisan claims" on the network made "in order to undercut John McCain." The claim in ...
Tom Tomorrow: The Revisionist
huffingtonpost.com 8/18/2008 — Bill Kristol, in the print edition of this morning's New York Times : NBC's Andrea Mitchell reported on "Meet the Press" that "the Obama people must feel that he didn't do quite as well as they might have wanted to in that context. ... What ...
Bill Kristol Quietly Revises Column On 'Cone Of Silence'
huffingtonpost.com 8/19/2008 — The New York Times ' Kit Seelye is backing up NBC's Andrea Mitchell , who reported on Sunday the contention that John McCain may not have been in the "cone of silence" before Saturday's Saddleback Chuch forum. But even as Seelye advances the story ...
The New York Times makes Bill Kristol look even stupider than usual
crooksandliars.com 8/19/2008 —   Boy, this is great. On the same day Bill Kristol says this : “NBC’s Andrea Mitchell reported on “Meet the Press” that “the Obama people must feel that he didn’t do quite as well as they might have wanted to in that context. […] ...
Kristol Revises his “Saddleback Showdown”The Moderate Voice
In this morning’s “Bill Kristol’s Cone of Silence,” I quoted Kristol from the online version of his New York Times column “Showdown at Saddleback.” In it Kristol wrote, as I quoted: NBC’s Andrea Mitchell reported on “Meet the Press” that “the Obama people must feel that he didn’t do quite as well as they might have wanted to in that context. … What ...
Andrea Mitchell repeats Axelrod’s talking pointsRathergate.com
David Axelrod is John McCain’s chief strategists. He invents talking points for McCain’s celebrity supporters. On yesterday’s journalists’ blah-blah on NBC’s Meet the Press, reporter Andrea Mitchell offered the rumor that for the Rick Warren candidates discussion at his Saddleback church, McCain “may not have been in the cone of silence and may have had [...]
NBC’s Mitchell Reveals How McCain Breached ConeScrappleFace
(2008-08-18) — NBC News correspondent Andrea Mitchell today explained how Sen. John McCain may have violated the ‘cone of silence’ at Saturday night’s forum with Pastor Rick Warren, allowing him to get a sneak preview of questions posed to Barack Obama before he took the stage to answer the same questions. Rumors that Sen. McCain broke Pastor Warren’s rules for ...
Dept. of pre-emptive outrageBen Smith's Blog
McCain campaign manager Rick Davis writes NBC to complain that Andrea Mitchell reported on the suggestion "that McCain may not have been in the cone of silence and may have had some ability to overhear what the questions were to Obama. He seemed so well prepared," as Mike Allen reports . Also, McCain's camp confirms he wasn't in the cone of silence, though there was no TV in the ...
McCain Camp Accuses NBC of Partisan CoverageDrudge Retort
The John McCain campaign fired off an angry letter to NBC News criticizing Andrea Mitchell's comments regarding McCain not being in a "cone of silence" at the faith forum at Saddleback Church. "We are concerned that your news division is following MSNBC's lead in abandoning nonpartisan coverage of the presidential race," campaign manager Rick Davis wrote.