Submit a Story!
topics:

National Journal Magazine - Firefighters Case: What Really Happened
OPENING ARGUMENT Firefighters Case: What Really Happened The more you examine the New Haven affirmative-action case, the more indefensible it looks. Saturday, June 13, 2009 by Stuart Taylor I admire many things about Judge Sonia Sotomayor, especially her deep compassion for underprivileged ...
Poll: GOP risks loss of respect if it goes after Sotomayor
mcclatchydc.com — WASHINGTON — Republicans may have a window of opportunity to turn public opinion against President Barack Obama's... first Supreme Court nominee, but a new poll finds that such a campaign could hurt their party's already weak standing with ... (more) Poll: GOP risks loss of respect if it goes after Sotomayor
Is Sonia Sotomayor Mean?
Is Sonia Sotomayor Mean?
npr.org — Nina Totenberg Morning Edition , June 15, 2009 The White House is fond of pointing out that... U.S. Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor has more years on the bench, as a trial court and appellate judge, than any previous Supreme Court nominee. With ... (more) Is Sonia Sotomayor Mean?
Miss Affirmative Action, 2009
humanevents.com — Having lost the Congress in 2006 and the White House in 2008, Republicans are looking to redefine... themselves for a nation that still leans conservative but is less Republican that it has been in decades. The nomination of Judge Sonia Sotomayor to the ... (more) Miss Affirmative Action, 2009
Comments
Blog Reactions

"What Really Happened" in Ricci :
The Volokh Conspiracy — Stuart Taylor may "admire many things about Judge Sonia Sotomayor," but his latest column raises concerns about the handling of Ricci v. DeStefano . The panel's decision to adopt as its own U.S. District Judge Janet Arterton's opinion in the case looks much less defensible up close than it does in most media accounts. One reason is that the detailed factual record strongly suggests that -- contrary to Sotomayor's position -- the Connecticut city's decision to kill the promotions was driven less by its purported legal concerns than by raw racial politics. Whichever way the ...

Happy Hour Links
Weekly Standard Blog — Jonah Goldberg: "von Brunn isn’t a member of the far right. Nor is he a member of the far left, as some on the right are claiming. He’s not a member of anything other than the crazy caucus." Charles Krauthammer: Obama Hovers From on High Stuart Taylor takes a close look at what really happened in Ricci v. DeStefano. Obama's DOJ backs DOMA. Chris Dodd's "controversial cottage in Ireland — purchased with a scandal-tainted New York financier — has doubled in value." Fox News ...

Discrimination Judicially Enforced If Sotomayor Had Her Way
Dr. Melissa Clouthier — ... And yet, Judge Sotomayor believes a person’s skin color is sufficient reason to force companies to give people raises or promotions. From Stuart Taylor of the National Journal: ...

Discrimination Judicially Enforced If Sotomayor Had Her Way
Right Wing News — ... of a promotion exam after too few minorities scored high enough on the test. Monday the Supreme Court, in a five to four vote, ruled in favor of the white firefighters. And of course, this kind of discrimination is "endemic": And fair-minded people are sick of the racial politics because it serves no one except Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton: And yet, Judge Sotomayor believes a person's skin color is sufficient reason to force companies to give people raises or promotions. From Stuart Taylor of the National Journal : The Sotomayor-endorsed position allowed such a "race-based ...

Related Content
National Journal Magazine - Firefighters Case: What Really Happened
nationaljournal.com 6/14/2009 — I admire many things about Judge Sonia Sotomayor, especially her deep compassion for underprivileged people. I may well support her confirmation to the Supreme Court if her testimony next month dispels my concern that her decisions may be biased by ...
Racism rejected: SCOTUS reverses Sotomayor in firefighters case
michellemalkin.com 6/29/2009 — President Obama applauds the decision as a victory for equality under the law. [...] Read the rest »
Firefighters to testify about Sotomayor
briefingroom.thehill.com 7/9/2009 — Republicans will call two New Haven firefighters to testify in the confirmation hearings of Sonia Sotomayor next week, making clear the GOP's intent to place affirmative action at the center of Senate battle over Sotomayor's nomination. A Judiciary ...
The Politics of the Sotomayor Nomination
scotusblog.com 6/1/2009 — I have pretty much been silent on the Sotomayor nomination because Tom, Kevin, and the other members of the blog have been doing an outstanding job in providing useful information to our readership. I found the multi-part coverage of Judge ...
Sonia Sotomayor: "Affirmative Action Baby"
weeklystandard.com 6/12/2009 — From the moment Sonia Sotomayor was nominated, Democrats have pointed to her academic pedigree as evidence that she is highly qualified for the job. Some conservatives doubted whether those credentials were, on their own, evidence of anything other ...
Why No Credit for Affirmative Action?
weeklystandard.com 6/9/2009 — Yesterday the New York Times stated as fact that Sotomayor "benefited from affirmative action policies" at both Princeton and Yale. Today William Bowen, the president of Princeton during Sotomayor's undergraduate years, praises Sotomayor effusively ...
Sotomayor: A Strong Choice for Supreme Court
tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com 6/12/2009 — Normal 0 false false false MicrosoftInternetExplorer4 st1\:*{behavior:url(#ieooui) } /* Style Definitions */ table.MsoNormalTable {mso-style-name:"Table ...
Obstruction 101: First Manufacture A Controversy
wonkroom.thinkprogress.org 6/12/2009 — Cribbing from a press release by the right-wing Judicial Confirmation Network (JCN), Republicans on the Senate Judiciary Committee drafted a letter claiming that Judge Sonia Sotomayor failed to disclose important information they need to evaluate her ...
Lowry: How Sotomayor Misspoke
article.nationalreview.com 6/2/2009 — Now we know. A few innocuous slips of the tongue made it seem that Sotomayor endorsed a racial essentialism, when she really meant to associate herself with race neutrality and impartiality.
Why Sotomayor rejected the New Haven firefighters' claim. - By Richard Thompson Ford - Slate Magazine
slate.com 5/27/2009 — Read more from Slate's coverage of Sonia Sotomayor’s nomination . Attorney Karen Torre and firefighter Frank Ricci. Click image to expand. Attorney Karen Torre and plaintiff Frank Ricci In 2003, the New Haven Fire Department decided to base promotions ...