Votes
National Journal Online -- National Security Experts -- Is Israel A Strategic Liability For The United States? (flag)
security.nationaljournal.com — Monday, January 5, 2009 Is Israel A Strategic Liability For The United States? As Israel escalates its efforts to root Hamas and its rocket launchers out of Gaza, the global reaction is increasingly negative -- except in the United States. Washington provides Israel with diplomatic backing, U.N. ...

vote down The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan found this 1/6/2009
Comments
2 Blogs Link to this Story

The Question At Hand
The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan — Sydney Freedberg asks whether Israel is a liability to the US: Yes, Israel and America cooperate on counterterrorism, but how many of the groups on which Israel provides intelligence would be gunning for the United States if it wasn't supporting Israel? Setting aside for a moment the emotional and religious anchors of the U.S.-Israel alliance, what is its value to the United States in practical, realpolitik terms? Michael Scheuer, Patrick Lang, Bruce Hoffman, Dov S. Zakheim, and James Carafano respond. ...

Israel: A Strategic Liability For The US?
Rantings of a Sandmonkey — ... And the other opinion comes from the previous principal officer in the US military intelligence relationship with Israel, and he had this to say: ...

Related Content
Israel and the United States: Up In Arms
www.antiwar.com 1/22/2009 — Excerpt: In answering questions before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, Secretary of State-designate Hillary Clinton acknowledged what she called the "tragic humanitarian costs of conflict in the Middle East, and the pain and suffering of ...
Excerpt: In answering questions before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, Secretary of State-designate Hillary Clinton acknowledged what she called the "tragic humanitarian costs of conflict in the Middle East, and the pain and suffering of ...
Can There Be Politics in Tragedy? Or in Gaza?
tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com 1/5/2009 — I'm immersed in long-range writing and leave tomorrow for six months in Berlin, but the Gaza war provokes me to share a brilliant essay by Darry Li, a doctoral student in anthropology and Middle East Studies at Harvard and a student at Yale Law ...
I'm immersed in long-range writing and leave tomorrow for six months in Berlin, but the Gaza war provokes me to share a brilliant essay by Darry Li, a doctoral student in anthropology and Middle East Studies at Harvard and a student at Yale Law ...
Today in The Nation: Gaza Attacks
www.thenation.com 1/9/2009 — Katrina vanden Heuvel UN Human Rights Rapporteur Richard Falk condemns Israeli airstrikes in Gaza and calls for a new approach to provide real protection for the Palestinian people.
Katrina vanden Heuvel UN Human Rights Rapporteur Richard Falk condemns Israeli airstrikes in Gaza and calls for a new approach to provide real protection for the Palestinian people.
Obama Demand: The Israeli Occupation Must End
tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com 12/14/2008 — It is becoming clear that Barack Obama understands that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is at the heart of virtually all of America's problems in the Middle East. He also understands that, paradoxically, it is the Middle East problem most ...
It is becoming clear that Barack Obama understands that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is at the heart of virtually all of America's problems in the Middle East. He also understands that, paradoxically, it is the Middle East problem most ...
Israel
www.balloon-juice.com 12/7/2008 — In a must-read post on settler violence, Hilzoy uttered the necessary mantra against trolls. Obligatory disclaimer for Israel/Palestinian threads: No one should draw any conclusions from this post about my general views on the Israeli/Palestinian ...
In a must-read post on settler violence, Hilzoy uttered the necessary mantra against trolls. Obligatory disclaimer for Israel/Palestinian threads: No one should draw any conclusions from this post about my general views on the Israeli/Palestinian ...
Israel Alone
pajamasmedia.com 1/5/2009 — I am writing this moments after the announcement of the Israel Defense Force that they have invaded Gaza . The first thing that struck me is that, for now at least, it is not Mark Steyn’s prescient America Alone . It is Israel Alone! Not ...
I am writing this moments after the announcement of the Israel Defense Force that they have invaded Gaza . The first thing that struck me is that, for now at least, it is not Mark Steyn’s prescient America Alone . It is Israel Alone! Not ...
The Evil and the Foolish
themoderatevoice.com 12/30/2008 — Though my own posts haven’t been bad, I think the folks over at Lawyers, Guns, and Money have probably the best package of coverage regarding Israel’s latest operation in Gaza. One of the things I think they’ve done effectively is ...
Though my own posts haven’t been bad, I think the folks over at Lawyers, Guns, and Money have probably the best package of coverage regarding Israel’s latest operation in Gaza. One of the things I think they’ve done effectively is ...
Invoking the Holocaust to Defend the Occuption
tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com 12/11/2008 — For American readers, the great virtue of Avraham Burg's important new book is that he says things about Israel and the Jewish people that are hardly ever heard in mainstream discourse in the United States. It is hard to believe how stunted and ...
For American readers, the great virtue of Avraham Burg's important new book is that he says things about Israel and the Jewish people that are hardly ever heard in mainstream discourse in the United States. It is hard to believe how stunted and ...
Enough Stupid Arguments About Israel
www.balloon-juice.com 12/31/2008 — Often simply naming something makes it easier to see and understand the next time. Take the argument that pressing crisis X demands some sort of immediate response is sufficient by itself to endorse reaction Y. This is plainly ridiculous. The ways ...
Often simply naming something makes it easier to see and understand the next time. Take the argument that pressing crisis X demands some sort of immediate response is sufficient by itself to endorse reaction Y. This is plainly ridiculous. The ways ...
My? Israel
tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com 2/9/2009 — My? Israel   As some of you know my wife and I have been seriously considering aliyah. We spent several weeks in November  in Israel exploring some of the details involved in such a move. We were somewhat optimistic at...
My? Israel   As some of you know my wife and I have been seriously considering aliyah. We spent several weeks in November  in Israel exploring some of the details involved in such a move. We were somewhat optimistic at...
Bush: Any Gaza truce must stop Hamas rocket fire — Reuters: Politics 1/5/2009
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. President George W. Bush said on Monday any ceasefire to end the Gaza crisis must include provisions that prevent Hamas from using the coastal strip to fire rockets into Israel.
Bush puts onus on Hamas for any Gaza truce — Reuters: Politics 1/5/2009
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. President George W. Bush insisted on Monday that any ceasefire to end the Gaza crisis must include provisions to prevent Hamas from continuing to use the coastal strip to fire rockets into Israel.
Wanted: Border Monitors to Oversee Gaza Truce — TIME.com Top Politics Stories 1/6/2009
The contours of a cease-fire deal between Israel and Hamas are emerging, with diplomacy focusing on international guarantees, including foreign border monitors to oversee any agreement.
Bush and Obama Consulted on Gaza — WSJ.com: Washington Wire 1/6/2009
John D. McKinnon reports on the White House. President George W. Bush and President-elect Barack Obama discussed the situation in Gaza briefly during a telephone call on New YearÂ’s Day, the White House confirmed. That appeared to suggest ...
Letters to the Editor — Christian Science Monitor | Commentary 1/6/2009
Readers write about extracting oil from shale and tar sands, the challenges Obama will face in Afghanistan, and how Hamas impedes the possibility of peace with Israel.