Submit a Story!
Newsweek: Obama echoes Bush on state secrets
When Eric Holder invoked the "state secrets" privilege to quash a lawsuit, his department's lawyers sounded a lot like those who worked for President Bush. In fact, they justified the action by filing an affidavit that is nearly identical to one filed by President Bush's intelligence director two years ago.
Obama Administration Invokes State Secrets Privilege…Again
Obama Administration Invokes State Secrets Privilege…Again
blogs.abcnews.com — The Obama administration invoked the controversial "state secrets" privilege again on Friday, arguing that if U.S. District... Judge Vaughn Walker were to permit a legal case against the government to proceed, he would be putting national security at ... (more) Obama Administration Invokes State Secrets Privilege…Again
Statement of Attorney General Eric Holder on Assertion of the State Secrets Privilege in Shubert ...
justice.gov — I authorized this significant step following a careful and thorough review process, and I did so only... because I believe there is no way for this case to move forward without jeopardizing ongoing intelligence activities that we rely upon to protect the ... (more) Statement of Attorney General Eric Holder on Assertion ...
Statement of Attorney General Eric Holder on Assertion of the State Secrets Privilege in Shubert ...
breitbart.com — WASHINGTON, Oct. 30 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- The Department of Justice invoked the state secrets privilege today in the... case Shubert, et al. v. Barack Obama, et al. Below is a statement by Attorney General Eric Holder: "The Department of Justice ... (more) Statement of Attorney General Eric Holder on Assertion ...
Comments
Blog Reactions

Obama Adopts Bush's State Secrets Position -- And Exact Language -- In NSA Spying Case
TPMMuckraker — Here's a good catch from Michael Isikoff on the new blog Declassified at Newsweek: It looks like the Obama Administration is invoking the state secrets privilege in a lawsuit alleging illegal surveillance by the National Security Agency -- and it's using the exact wording used by the Bush Administration two years ago in the very same case. Isikoff compares the two passages from filings in the case, now titled Shubert v. Obama: "It is my judgment that sensitive state secrets are so central to the subject matter of the ...

Related Content
State Secrets Critics Slam New Obama Policy
washingtonindependent.com 9/24/2009 — Although the Obama administration’s much-anticipated new policy on the use of the so-called “state secrets” privilege, announced this morning , has drawn some praise, civil liberties lawyers and other critics of the use of the privilege don’t think it ...
In Spy Case, Obama’s Justice Department Holds Fast to State Secrets Privilege — Update
wired.com 10/8/2009 — Holder_660px The Obama administration is invoking the state secrets privilege for the second time this week, this time in a closely watched spy case weighing whether a U.S. president may bypass Congress and establish a program of eavesdropping on ...
Justice Department to Limit Use of State Secrets Privilege
nytimes.com 9/23/2009 — Justice Department to Limit Use of State Secrets Privilege
Newsweek: How Obama is like both presidents Bush
newsweek.com 10/19/2009 — Barack Obama is a lot more like Bush 41 than anyone involved—including Obama and Bush 43—would readily admit. At their best, both of them have worked to govern as presidents, not as partisans, which is the way good men have always conducted themselves ...
Obama, Bush And State Secrets
andrewsullivan.theatlantic.com 2/11/2009 — I think we may be in danger of reading too much into non-decisions made early that may well be best explained as a holding pattern as the new president tries to get a grip on what exactly he is inheriting. Ambers does some, you know, reporting on the ...
Obama Tightens State Secrets Standard
washingtonpost.com 9/23/2009 — New Policy May Affect Wiretap, Torture Suits By Carrie Johnson Washington Post Staff Writer Wednesday, September 23, 2009 3:15 PM The Obama administration on Wednesday announced a new policy making it much more difficult for the government to claim ...
Justice Dept. to Limit Use of State Secrets Privilege
nytimes.com 9/23/2009 — Justice Dept. to Limit Use of State Secrets Privilege
Bush-Era Leaks Were Dangerous After All
powerlineblog.com 29 days ago — Attorney General Eric Holder yesterday invoked the state secrets privilege in connection with a case titled Shubert, et al. v. Barack Obama, et al. . The Shubert case is pending in federal district court in San Francisco. Assuming the court agrees ...
Obama Admin. Announces New Policy On State Secrets
tpmmuckraker.talkingpointsmemo.com 9/23/2009 — Over the last few months, we've given voice to concerns that the Obama administration has been mimicking its predecessor in its approach to executive power and the war on terror -- in particular by invoking the states secrets privilege in seeking to ...
Obama’s New State Secrets Policy is Reaffirmation Of Bush’s Policy
emptywheel.firedoglake.com 9/23/2009 — Back in mid June , testifying before the Senate Judiciary Committee, Attorney General Eric Holder announced that the Obama Administration's long promised new policy on state secrets use would be revealed "within days". Over three months ...
Taking down failures: Who pays, when and how much? (AP)Yahoo! News: Politics News 27 days ago
AP - House Democrats are balking at an Obama administration plan that would put taxpayers on the hook for up to five years to dismantle any giant financial firm whose failure could repeat last year's Wall Street collapse.
In Iowa, Euphoria Gives Way to Second Thoughts on ObamaNYT > Politics 27 days ago
The president’s standing has fallen in the state that jump-started his campaign, especially among independents and Republicans.
Books of The Times: The Obama the Campaign KnewNYT > Politics 27 days ago
Two new books look back at the Obama campaign.
Obama warns on job losses, urges export boost (Reuters)Yahoo! News: Politics News 27 days ago
Reuters - U.S. President Barack Obama warned on Monday that more U.S. job losses lay ahead despite a turnaround in the economy, and he called for a new "post bubble growth model" with greater focus on U.S. exports.
Obama urged to factor WTO issue into tanker contest (Reuters)Yahoo! News: Politics News 27 days ago
Reuters - Forty U.S. lawmakers backing Boeing Co urged President Barack Obama on Monday to ensure a new Air Force competition for aerial refueling planes takes account of alleged illegal subsidies received by Airbus.