Submit a Story!
The Debate: The All-Important Grumpiness Factor
The Debate: The All-Important Grumpiness Factor
Here’s the politically incorrect way of phrasing one of the central questions about tonight’s presidential debate: Did John McCain come across as too much of a grumpy old man? That might not be a nice question, but it’s an important one. Americans like to vote for the nice guy, not the ...
Comments
Blog Reactions

Seems everyone noticed McCain's sneers, anger and contempt
AMERICAblog News| A great nation deserves the truth — ... And, yeah, it was really weird and immature that McCain never looked at Obama. Eugene Robinson also picked up on McCain's bad attitude: ...

Open Thread for Night Owls, Early Birds & Ex-Pats
Daily Kos — A lot of pundits and commenters and some Diarists are abuzz over why John McCain didn't look at Barack Obama even once during the debate Friday night. Rude, say some. Arrogant, say some. Condescending and contemptuous, say others. Passive-aggressive outrage, say still others, a lack of eye contact meant as an insult to Obama - not a planned insult, but because McCain is just that kind of person who can't bear to think of others as equals, who was pissed off that this other person was even allowed on the same stage as him - a king, having to mingle with ...

One more reaction thread
Daily Kos — ... an did what he needed to do to reassure people. Richard Wolffe, MSNBC: That was the greatest contrast…the demeanor and the tone of voice that these candidates adopted where McCain was being much more pointed much more aggressive and curiously couldn't look Obama in the eye. Obama's tone much more straight and even keeled but ready to look his opponent in the eye repeatedly. A big contrast. Eugene Robinson, Washington Post: Here’s the politically incorrect way of phrasing one of the ...

What a night
WTF Is It Now?!? — ... Eugene Robinson: Here’s the politically incorrect way of phrasing one of the central questions about tonight’s presidential debate: Did John McCain come across as too much of a grumpy old man? That might not be a nice question, but it’s an important one. ...

Post-Debate Blah-Blah-Blahage
Jules Crittenden — ... .  Here’s one Obamist who thinks McCain came across as contempuous, grumpy. WPost’s Robinson  must have been watching a different debate Sargent, as was Sargent’s boss. ...

The Morning After
The Mahablog — ... Obama doesn’t understand,” or found some other way to sneer at Obama as naive and inexperienced. For the most part he refused to even look at Barack Obama over 90 minutes. What an ass. It was hackneyed and condescending and, to me, repellent. But did it work? … …I think Obama more than held his own in this first debate, but if you’re looking for a grumpy, sarcastic put-down artist as president, your choice is quite clear. Eugene Robinson: Throughout the 90-minute debate, McCain seemed contemptuous ...

The Narrative Starts to Settle In
Balloon Juice — ... You can lament that this stuff should be all about the issues, or you can accept the reality that this sort of stuff killed Gore. Bob Somerby still is furious about it. At any rate, it was sighs and eye-rolling in 2000, but in 2008 it will be anger, contempt, and the refusal to make eye contact. take it way, Eugene Robinson: ...

When Do Political Ads Go Too Far?
Taylor Marsh — ... If John McCain was a happier warrior, maybe this wouldn’t even be an issue. But he’s not, so it is. All of it stems from the "grumpy old man factor," which was on display ...

Beyond Words
democracyarsenal.org — ... In the analysis of last night’s debate, much attention has been paid to John McCain’s body language. McCain’s refusal to look at Barack Obama, his hunched and combative stance, and his facial tics all contributed to making him look disrespectful, “grumpy,” and ...

McCain's anger and fear dominated the debates
culturekitchen - fresh dissent served daily — ... Obama not only brought out the "grumpy old man" in McCain. I don't think though that it wasn't just contempt that moved McCain to never make eye contact with Obama. I truly believe McCain couldn't look at Obama because he was afraid of losing it. To the point that at one point his face looked disjointed, like an an ugly mask. ...

Related: mccain grumpy debate, debate central
Election Central Morning Roundup
tpmelectioncentral.talkingpointsmemo.com 9/26/2008 — Tonight: The Debate The first presidential debate is scheduled for 9 p.m. ET tonight at the University of Mississippi. Barack Obama will be showing up, while John McCain has not committed to coming yet. McCain will probably show up in the end, but ...
Programming note - debate edition
norunnyeggs.com 9/26/2008 — While the liveblog promo said I would be kicking things off at 6:45 pm, I had assumed that the debate would start at 7 pm CDT. I forgot that Mississippi is in the Central Time Zone, so that will kick off at 7:45 pm, with the thread containing the Cover It Live widget going up at 7:30 pm. Both ...
Health Care Hits Debate and "The Grumpy Old Man" FactorWashblog - Diaries
With the recent economic crisis the door to domestic issues was opened during the first presidential debate and with this came health care. The answers were predictable, but showed a clear difference between McCain and Obama. Obama appealed to the middle class by noting a recent report ...
John on CNN last nightAMERICAblog News| A great nation deserves the truth
Embedded video from CNN Video I just finished watching the debate and agree, Obama had a good evening. What I liked was CNN's meter at the bottom of the screen as the candidates spoke. Every time McCain went nasty or grumpy (and he did it a lot) the numbers plummeted for Democrats, Republicans ...
The Smirk: Could McCain's Facial Gestures Define Debate?Politics on HuffingtonPost.com
As the spin of Friday night's debate settled in and both sides staked a claim to victory, a meme began to take hold: while Obama may have been over-complimentary of McCain in the eyes of many Democrats, McCain was grumpy, mean, and downright contemptuous of Obama, much to his detriment. A ...
The Smirk: Could McCain's Facial Gestures Define Debate?The Huffington Post | Full News Feed
As the spin of Friday night's debate settled in and both sides staked a claim to victory, one media narrative began to take hold: while Obama may have been over-complimentary of McCain, the GOP nominee was grumpy, mean, and downright contemptuous of Obama, much to his detriment. A clip ...
Comment on A Little Worried, and Open Debate Thread by Dan M.Comments for Lean Left
Maybe this is my bias showing, but it seemed to me that McCain spent a lot of time trying to attack Obama, while Obama spent a lot of his time pointing out that McCain was lying about him. While McCain didn’t exactly sound grumpy, he seemed to say that him primary appeal was that he ...
Debate Wrap-Up: Obama Didn’t Hurt HimselfFiredoglake
McCain controlled the debate tonight. He came off as a brittle, grumpy, mean-spirited old coot, but on the economy -- which should have been Obama's strong suit -- McCain managed to divert the conversation to tax cuts and kept Obama off the kitchen table issues where he excels. McCain was ...
Election Central Morning RoundupTalking Points Memo
Polls show McCain's lead slipping, and within the margin of error, in Florida and Missouri. That and the day's other political news (did someone say debate?) in the TPM Election Central Morning Roundup .