Submit a Story!
The Problem With a Special Prosecutor
The Problem With a Special Prosecutor
Want the truth on torture? A Patrick Fitzgerald-style investigation may be the wrong way to go.
Turley: We Need A Special Torture Prosecutor, Not Some Lame Commission
tpmmuckraker.talkingpointsmemo.com — Jonathan Turley, the media-friendly George Washington Law School professor, who's an outspoken advocate of curbing executive power,... gave a bravura performance on MSNBC's Countdown last night, on the subject of possible torture prosecutions.  ... (more) Turley: We Need A Special Torture Prosecutor, Not Some ...
Comments
Blog Reactions

The Problem with a Special Prosecutor on Torture
David Corn — ... There's been a lot of calls on the left for a special prosecutor to investigate the Bush administration's use of torture (or enhanced interrogation techniques, if you're Dick Cheney). While a special prosecutor might be necessary to determine if any crimes were committed, the appointment of a Patrick Fitzgerald-like investigator would in no way guarantee that the public will learn the full truth about this affair. As I write for Mother Jones: ...

Prosecute, Investigate or Move On?
Opinionator — ... is that last notion — “only those who torture can be trusted” — that Danner said must be dealt with. And doing so is very much about looking forward, not backward: To expose this dark counter-narrative to the light of day, to flood it with light and then destroy it, is the vital political task, not only for today but for tomorrow, when the pressures to believe it, in the wake of a further act of mass destruction could well prove irresistible. At Mother Jones today, David Corn also makes the case for investigation over prosecution , but from a different angle. Corn says that ...

In Search Of Sunlight
The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan — David Corn doesn't like the idea of a special prosecutor: These liberals all want to see alleged Bush administration wrongdoing exposed. But there's one problem with a special prosecutor: it's not his job to expose wrongdoing. A special prosecutor does dig up facts--but ...

I Agree With David Corn
JustOneMinute — I agree with David Corn in believing that appointing a special counsel to poke at the terror debacle makes no sense.  Prosecutors are not looking for "the truth" - they are looking for crimes they can indict and successfully prosecute, and most of what they find ends up hidden behind grand jury secrecy rules and never presented in court. That said, Corn and I differ here: Fitzgerald didn't investigate "the Bush Administration" "forcefully and thoroughly" - he put the White House under a microscope and gave the State Department a pass.  Come on - Richard Armitage confessed ...

Jeremy Scahill: What if Instead of the Nuremberg Trials There Was Only a Truth Commission?
Politics on HuffingtonPost.com — ... This week it is Mother Jones Washington editor David Corn, who comes out in favor of a congressional investigation "that placed a premium on public disclosure" or "an independent commission." Corn describes how he recently warned a Congressmember who supports the appointment of a Special Prosecutor, "That's not necessarily a good idea." Corn talks about how a coalition of groups from the Center for Constitutional Rights and the ACLU to Democrats.com and MoveOn.org have all petitioned for a prosecutor: ...

Question Time for Cheney?
David Corn — ... The hearing with Zelikow is a start, but he's already said he doesn't know who in the White House attempted to eradicate his own memo. Whether or not there's a special prosecutor or a truth commission, congressional investigators should request all these records and start grilling the participants. And since Cheney is so eager to talk about this stuff these days, maybe they should begin with him. Given that he's called for disclosing information about the interrogation program, he shouldn't mind answering a few questions, right? ...

Related Content
BREAKING: Ask Obama For a Torture Special Prosecutor
thenation.com 12/30/2008 — The Obama transition team is taking questions again at Change.gov , throwing open the site this week for citizen input. The first run of this experiment was a mixed bag. The platform was open and transparent, but the official answers felt more like ...
FDL Action | Special Prosecutor
action.firedoglake.com 4/16/2009 — President Obama released four memoranda from the Bush Justice Department that sets forth in graphic detail the torture techniques that were authorized and ordered by the highest officials in our government. These techniques are indisputably crimes, ...
Prosecutor questions Rove on fired US attorneys (AP)
news.yahoo.com 5/15/2009 — AP - Former White House aide Karl Rove is meeting with a special prosecutor weighing whether to bring criminal charges against Bush administration officials for the politically charged firing of U.S. attorneys.
Lawrence Wilkerson: Disbar The Bush Lawyers And Get A Special Prosecutor For The Rest
huffingtonpost.com 4/27/2009 — Colin Powell's former chief of staff called on Friday for a special prosecutor to be appointed and "armed to the teeth" to investigate the authorization of torture by Bush administration officials. He also stated that the lawyers involved in drafting ...
Special Prosecutor for Bush War Crimes
democrats.com 12/20/2008 — Dear Attorney General-Designate Eric Holder, We the undersigned citizens of the United States hereby formally petition you to appoint a Special Prosecutor to investigate and prosecute any and all government officials who have participated in War ...
So What's the Problem?
talkingpointsmemo.com 1/5/2009 — Since my earlier post was more arch and cryptic, I wanted to expand on what seems to be the problem with the Obama stimulus plan, as revealed in the current round of leaks. I would point to three key issues. And I'm going to base these three on the ...
Prosecutor: Drop case against Bush officials
cnn.com 4/16/2009 — Garzon says the case can be brought under Spanish law because several Spaniards were held at Guantanamo.
Obama on whether he'll appoint a special prosecutor to investigate Bush (video)
youtube.com 1/11/2009 — This Week with George Stephanopoulos
The Real Problem
blackfive.net 4/20/2009 — Wounded Warriors in the Boston Marathon | Main | RIP Colonel Blanchard The Real Problem Posted By Blackfive Some of you may be wondering why we've been so silent on the DHS memos. We've been working the issue from the inside out, trying to get to ...
Encourage Obama to Appoint a Special Prosecutor for Bush Administration
democrats.com 12/30/2008 — At Change.gov, President-Elect Obama is inviting a second round of questions. At the end of the first round, our Special Prosecutor question was #6 but Obama's team only answered the first five. This time let's get our question to #1!  ...