Submit a Story!
They Both Lost
They both lost tonight. We can go back and forth about whether McCain's anecdotes were more intimate or whether Obama's jabs were snappier. But beyond stylistic differences in the personalities they project from behind the podium (McCain's the weary parent, Obama's the sharp young know-it-all), ...
Comments
Blog Reactions

Reading New Republic Tea Leaves to Determine Debate Winner
NewsBusters.org - Exposing Liberal Media Bias — ... The first story chosen for this liberal tea leaf reading is titled, "They Both Lost." This was way too easy. What the title really tells you, without even having to read the story, is "McCain Won." The article itself merely confirms what was pretty much shouted out in the title (emphasis mine): ...

Post-Debate Blah-Blah-Blahage
Jules Crittenden — ... We’ll kick off with The New Republic , which apparently thinks Obama stunk the place up, given its “They both lost” take. TNR and I agree on one point. The whole debate was weirdly imitative. You brag about your soldier’s bracelet, I’ll brag about my soldier’s bracelet! Obama was more afflicted with this imitation disorder — he called for giving Georgia and Ukraine NATO Membership Action Plans “immediately,” a stance Sarah Palin was derided for taking in her interview with Charlie Gibson, and McCain has already released a ...

An Election About Nothing (II)
Ross Douthat — Eve Fairbanks, on the debate: McCain and Obama are two of the most exceptional political figures of their generations, so expansive in their own visions of what they represent. But you wouldn't have known that if you were, say, a Martian tuning in to this campaign for the first time. Neither of them really faced the bailout head-on, sharply differentiated themselves from the other, or (most disappointing of all) tried to offer a big argument or central narrative about what's wrong with the country. Sometimes, their positions even seemed to converge. The two ...

Related Content
Paul Reiser: Obama Underwhelms, McCain Patronizes
huffingtonpost.com 9/27/2008 — Well, for the first few minutes of the debate it was like watching a bad Dr. Phil show. "That was great -- now I want you to turn around and say what you just said, but now say it to him . Let him hear you." It was well intentioned but goofy -- ...
So Angry
talkingpointsmemo.com 9/27/2008 — McCain's unwillingness to make eye contact with Obama through the debate seems to be getting picked up by a lot of observers. Here's an interesting exchange on the subject between Chris Matthews and the Post's Eugene Robinson ... Here's ...
McCain gets a slight edge among 14 undecided Pennsylvania voters
latimes.com 9/27/2008 — An unscientific experiment shows that both candidates have a lot of work to do among those still on the fence. > To a small cross section of crucial voters ...
Why Voters Thought Obama Won
fivethirtyeight.com 9/27/2008 — TPM has the internals of the CNN poll of debate-watchers, which had Obama winning overall by a margin of 51-38. The poll suggests that Obama is opening up a gap on connectedness , while closing a gap on readiness . Specifically, by a 62-32 margin, ...
CBS Poll: Obama Boosted Most By Debate, Uncommitted Voters Give Edge To Obama On Economy, McCain On Iraq
cbsnews.com 9/27/2008 — (CBS) The first presidential debate helped uncommitted voters learn about the candidates - and it appears that Democrat Barack Obama benefited the most, according to a CBS News/Knowledge Networks poll taken immediately following the debate. ...
Analysis: Few jabs, but no knockout in first debateCNN.com - Politics 9/27/2008
Sens. John McCain and Barack Obama landed some punches Friday night, but neither delivered a knockout blow in the first presidential debate featuring the two party nominees.
Round 1 in debates goes to Obama, poll saysCNN.com - Politics 9/27/2008
A national poll of people who watched the first presidential debate suggests that Barack Obama came out on top, but there was overwhelming agreement that both Obama and John McCain would be able to handle the job of president if elected.  ...
With debate over, a return to the economyPOLITICO.com: Politics 9/27/2008
Senators Barack Obama and John McCain left Mississippi Friday night and returned to a campaign hinged on the economy. See also: Debate Analysis
Debate done, bailout retakes center stage (Politico)Yahoo! News: Politics News 9/27/2008
Politico - OXFORD — Senators Barack Obama and John McCain left this college town Friday night and returned to a campaign that continues to be strapped to the nation’s financial crisis and Washington’s stalled attempt to solve it.
Obama and Biden: Together Again for the First TimeWSJ.com: Washington Wire 9/27/2008
Amy Chozick reports on the presidential race in Greensboro, North Carolina. Barack Obama campaigned with running mate Joe Biden for the first time since he named the Delaware senator as his vice presidential pick last month. The duo held ...