motherjones.com - 12/17/2008
—
TORTURE.... Responding to Andrew Sullivan, Reuel Marc Gerecht defends his defense of torture:
I take it from your post that if you had been confronted on 7 September 2001 with a captured Khalid Shaykh Muhammad or Abu Zubaydah and you knew that a major, mass-casualty terrorist strike was about ...
nytimes.com - 12/18/2008
—
nytimes.com —
A prosecutor should be appointed to consider criminal
charges against top officials at the Pentagon for decisions
that led to the abuse, torture and death in prisons run by the American military and intelligence services. >
(more)
Editorial: The Torture Report
news.bbc.co.uk - 12/19/2008
—
news.bbc.co.uk —
Decades after a notorious experiment, scientists have found
test subjects are still willing to inflict pain on
others - if told to by an authority figure. US researchers repeated the famous "Milgram test", with volunteers told to deliver electrical ...
(more)
BBC NEWS | Health | People 'still willing to torture'
washingtonpost.com - 12/23/2008
—
washingtonpost.com —
Comments that include profanity or personal attacks or
other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from
the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. ...
(more)
5 Myths About Torture and Truth
Comments
Blog Reactions
In Defense Of Torture, Ctd.
The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan —
Drum wonders: ....even for torture apologists like Gerecht, I wonder how far they're willing to go. He must know that over the past few years we've tortured a steady and sizeable stream of people who were either decidedly small fish or else just completely innocent. How many of those people is he willing to brutalize on the slim chance that once, someday, we'll just happen to have someone in our custody who knows about a terrorist plot scheduled for tomorrow and can be successfully tortured into giving it up in time? Dozens? Hundreds? Thousands? Where ...
On Torture: The Will Of The People
TalkLeft —
Responding to Reuel Marc Gerecht's defense of his pro-torture position, Kevin Drum writes: Sadly, I suspect that Gerecht is right: if torture had been put to a vote back in 2001, it would have passed. The language would have been prettied up, of course, but the intention would have been clear enough and the public would have approved. Even today, I'm pretty sure that a majority of Americans are basically OK with torture as long as it's mostly kept out of sight and they can go about their business. Drum begs the question - ...
Of Coups, Purges, Torture and Shoes
Obsidian Wings —
... But whose to say the use of torture should be outlawed in The New Iraq? What if al-Zaydi knew of a ticking shoe bomb that was about to go off somewhere in Iraq? Therefore, the use of torture is entirely ...
Related: gerecht in defense of torture
In Defense Of Torture
andrewsullivan.theatlantic.com 12/16/2008 — Reuel Marc Gerecht responds to my postings yesterday: I take it from your post that if you had been confronted on 7 September 2001 with a captured Khalid Shaykh Muhammad or Abu Zubaydah and you knew that a major, mass-casualty terrorist strike was ...
In Defense Of Torture, Ctd —
The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan
A reader writes: Gerecht, in his response to you, offers one torture justification that
cries for amplification: Sixty-five years ago Americans no doubt were
responsible for atrocities that shamed all involved, as he rightly
points out. But what he fails to add is that those atrocities ...