Submit a Story!
Who's rich? McCain and Obama have very different definitions - Los Angeles Times
Even so, the remark highlighted the candidates' disparate outlooks. Analysts who study income distribution said the answers appeared to reflect shifting political calculations more than economic reality. Economists said in interviews Sunday that neither candidate was wrong because there are no agreed-upon definitions for the terms that describe income segments. "To be fair to both of them, ...
Comments
Blog Reactions

Laughable: How McCain Abuses The Humor Card
The Huffington Post | Full News Feed — ... This week, the humor crutch is being leaned on again. As initial reports out of the Rick Warren's Saddleback Forum made note of McCain's definition of "the rich" as those who earn more than $5 million in annual salary, we're now told the key to understanding the candidate's answer to a serious question is that he was only joking. ...

McCain says you're "rich" when you make $5m a year
AMERICAblog NewsWeird. Though Obama said it's when you make $250,000 a year. I'd posit another definition. Look at people's personal wealth - income from all sources, money saved for retirement, value of their home and other assets, debts, cost of living where they live - then decide if they're rich. It's simply phony to compare someone who lives in NY or DC to someone who lives in Topeka, and only look at their salaries. It's even phonier to look at someone who put themselves through 8 or more years of university and is paying that debt off for 15 years, and not count their debt against ...

People Who Live in Seven Glass Houses….
Political Punch — ... "Who's he talking to?" Obama asked. Then he cited McCain's "joke" from the forum at Saddleback Church when he offered to Pastor Rick Warren the definition that someone who's rich is someone who makes $5 million a year . "I guess if you're only making $3 million a year then you're middle class," Obama said. "I guess that's what he meant." Obama then cited the ...

The McCain-Obama house debate pins the gaffe-ometer
Top of the Ticket — ... . "It's condominiums where — I'll have them get to you." The staff response: Four homes. The reality: Seven homes. Not a good flub for the candidate who the other day defined (in a joke, the campaign said later) being rich as making $5 million a year (what's so bad about $4 million?), and whose economic surrogate thinks most voters concerned about their own deteriorating financial well-being are just a ...

Mitchell Bard: August 21, 2008: The Day John McCain's Campaign Died
Politics on HuffingtonPost.com — ... for a candidate to be "average" is insane, but that's a discussion for a different article.) Yesterday, McCain had his windsurfing moment. When asked how many houses he and his wife owned, McCain said he didn't know and would have to check with his staffers. After the McCain campaign said the answer was at least four, Obama later happily pointed out that, in fact, the McCains had seven homes. If McCain's remark last week at Rick Warren's values forum about $5 million being the threshold for being "rich" (watch for yourself here) didn't sink ...

Math Hurts Head
Sadly, No! — ... Remember when McCain said his definition of ‘rich’ is people who make $5 million or more a year? A pal of mine pointed out last night that high-yield savings account interest rates top out at about 4%. That means you’d need about $125 million in the bank to get back $5 million a year. ...

America: Yours, Mine, and Ours - Pt. 1
The Republic of T. — ... — reversing a trend of upward mobility that began in the previous decade and ended around the time this one began. It’s light years away from the America where and income of $5 million qualifies as “rich” and ...

Daniel Kurtzman: McCain and Palin In Their Own Words: 25 Laughable Quotes
Politics on HuffingtonPost.com — ... 10. "I think if you're just talking about income, how about $5 million?" ―McCain, after being asked by Rev. Rick Warren to define "rich," Lake Forest, California, Aug. 16, 2008 (Source) ...

Related Content
McCain: 'Gotta keep your sense of humor'
swamppolitics.com 8/18/2008 — by Mark Silva John McCain offered an off-the-cuff remark about a top-selling book that is off-the-mark on rival Barack Obama that drew an off-the-charts response from the Democratic Party. Friday morning, McCain was asked by a reporter ...
Did we mention that he was a POW?
sideshow.me.uk 8/18/2008 — There's been a lot of discussion about whether Rick Warren's people made sure McCain (but not Obama) had the questions for the forum in advance. Here's a section from the transcripts that suggests that's the case: 8 Q OKAY. WE DON'T HAVE TO GO ...
DNC Convention Credentials Feature Upside-Down Flag
newsbusters.org 8/18/2008 — Having seen photo propaganda used in the media to benefit Barack Obama, one has to wonder if it will be equally important to circulate a picture that may not show the 'savior' in a particularly good light. As such, a ticket design for the ...
Obama Mocks McCain’s Definition of 'Rich'
blogs.abcnews.com 8/19/2008 — ABC News' Sunlen Miller Reports: Senator Obama made light of Senator McCain’s definition of “rich” at Saturday’s Saddleback forum in California, suggesting that even though McCain may have been a joking, it still demonstrates McCain’s mindset in ...
McCain Cites POW Status in Denying He Cheated at Evangelical Forum
pensitoreview.com 8/18/2008 — Did John McCain cheat by cribbing questions in advance at the rightwing megachurch forum Saturday night? UPDATE McCain operative Nicole Wallace vehemently denied claims that McCain heard Barack Obama being questioned, even though McCain was not ...
McCain defends vets card, raps ObamaFirst Read 8/18/2008
From NBC/NJ’s Adam Aigner-Treworgy and NBC’s Domenico Montanaro ORLANDO, Fla. -- McCain also defended his call for a Veterans’ Care Access Card in his speech at the VFW Convention here today by saying that it was an “expansion” of the VA not a ...
Newsweek: What McCain, Obama have in commonmsnbc.com: Politics 8/18/2008
In many ways, the differences between John McCain and Barack Obama could not be more vivid. And yet the parallels, in life stories and approaches to politics, are as remarkable as the differences.
Obama rips McCain for $5 million "rich" definitionReuters: Politics 8/18/2008
ALBUQUERQUE, New Mexico (Reuters) - How much money makes a person rich?
Obama, McCain react to MusharrafCNN Political Ticker 8/18/2008
(CNN) – Both Barack Obama and John McCain have released statements reacting to the resignation of Pakistan's President Pervez Musharraf: Read the statements after the jump Obama: "President Musharraf has made the right decision to step down as ...
Obama Takes Issue with McCain’s Definition of ‘Rich’FOXNews.com 8/18/2008
Barack Obama seized the opportunity Monday to criticize comments made by his opponent John McCain over the weekend in which the presumptive GOP nominee defined wealthy Americans as those who make an income of $5 million or more. “He [McCain] ...