Submit a Story!
Why was it so hard for Dems even to start health care debate?
By: Byron York Chief Political Correspondent 11/21/09 6:43 PM EST The extraordinary thing about the dramatic events surrounding the health care bill in the Senate is that there is any drama in it at all. Lawmakers are simply voting to begin debate on their version of health care reform. Just ...
Nelson Hints Strongly That He'll Vote With Dems To Bring Health Reform To Floor
tpmlivewire.talkingpointsmemo.com — Sen. Ben Nelson (D-NE) released a statement on a motion to proceed to debate health care reform... legislation. Ben Nelson - Healthcare reform - Legislation - Senate - Congressional Budget Office (more) Nelson Hints Strongly That He'll Vote With Dems To Bring ...
Nelson: Let's Debate This Health Care Bill
tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com — Ben Nelson holds out no longer. He will vote to move a health care bill to the... floor this weekend. (more) Nelson: Let's Debate This Health Care Bill
Senate Dems suggest they're open to altering health care bill
Senate Dems suggest they're open to altering health care bill
cnn.com — Senate Dems suggest they're open to altering health care bill... (more) Senate Dems suggest they're open to altering health care ...
Comments
Blog Reactions

The Bad News for Democrats -- By: Kathryn Jean Lopez
The Corner on National Review Online — is that there was any drama today at all. Byron York writes: the Democrats' problems in keeping their side together, in the face of united Republican opposition, is an indicator of how public opinion is beginning to dominate the health care debate. Dozens of polls show that Americans are deeply divided over the issue, with a slight plurality opposing the Democratic health care plans currently under consideration in Congress. Clear majorities of Americans don't believe their health care will improve under the plan, and don't believe the plan will not increase ...

Senate Approves Motion to Proceed on Obamacare
Stop The ACLU — ... Posted on November 21, 2009 -By Warner Todd Huston With a 60 to 39 vote, the Senate has passed the motion to proceed to move on with the debate over Obamacare. Again, it is important to note that this is only a vote to begin the floor debate on the bill. It is not a vote to pass Obamacare. In the Washington Examiner, Byron York has an excellent point when he asks , “why was it so hard for Democrats even to start the healthcare debate?” The extraordinary thing about the dramatic events surrounding the health care bill in the Senate is that there is any drama in it at all. ...

How John Hoeven Can Save America
GayPatriot — ... Neither his name nor that of his senior colleague was on the list of the wavering Democrats, those who might have voted for cloture.  Like Conrad, Dorgan’s drunk his party’s Kool-aid, convinced that his regular visits home and friendly manner will continue to endear him to his constituents.  But, if the popular Republican Governor of his state decided to throw his hat into the ring, well, then, Dorgan could no longer rest on his manner and constituent service.  He would have to fight for his seat. ...

BYRON YORK: Why was it so hard for Dems even to start health care debate?…
Instapundit — BYRON YORK: Why was it so hard for Dems even to start health care debate?

60 the hard way
Tertium Quids — Byron York on why it was so difficult for senate Democrats to get the 60 votes necessary to being debate on Harry Reid's health insurance bill: But the Democrats' problems in keeping their side together, in the face of united Republican opposition, are an indicator of how public opinion is beginning to dominate the health care debate. Dozens of polls show that Americans are deeply divided over the issue, with a slight plurality opposing the Democratic health care plans currently under consideration in Congress. Clear majorities of Americans don't believe their health care ...

Some Things Are Certain
The Mahablog — ... Someone on the Right will explain why the accomplishment was not, in fact, an accomplishment, but a failure. Or a sign of weakness. Or a portent of failures to come. ...

A Little Senate 101
PoliBlog: A Rough Draft of my Thoughts — In the Washington Examiner Byron York writes:  Why was it so hard for Dems even to start health care debate? The extraordinary thing about the dramatic events surrounding the health care bill in the Senate is that there was any drama at all. Lawmakers were simply voting to begin debate on the Democratic version of health care reform. Just begin debate — not end it, and not move on to a final vote. If Democrats, with a 60-vote majority in the Senate, had not been able to begin debate on the top Democratic policy ...

Quote of the Day: Why Was It So Difficult for Democrats to Start Health Care Debate?
The Moderate Voice — Some pundits are now asking why it was so hard for the Democrats to start the health care debate in the nail-biting vote yesterday where GOPers were solidly against letting the bill go up for discussion and the Demmies were solidly for it? Political scientist Steven Taylor points to this piece in particular that asks the question. And Taylor — as usual — stands back and gives us his take on the issue, minus any talk show like rhetoric of the left and right. And it’s our political Quote of the Day: However, what it is ...

Related Content
A Little Senate 101
poliblogger.com 11/22/2009 — In the Washington Examiner Byron York writes:  Why was it so hard for Dems even to start health care debate? The extraordinary thing about the dramatic events surrounding the health care bill in the Senate is that there was any drama at all. ...
Obama and Dems on Health Care: No Need to Rush
politicsdaily.com 11/24/2009 — Shortly after Senate Democrats on Saturday night succeeded in winning a party-line 60-39 vote that allows their health care reform bill to reach the Senate floor, CNN correspondent Ed Henry zapped out a message to his Twitter followers about a White ...
Top Dems: Obama Won't Get Health Care Bill in 2009
abcnews.go.com 11/4/2009 — Senior congressional Democrats now saw reform before end of year is highly unlikely.
WATCH: Senate Dems Claim 'V' on Health Care
abcnews.go.com 11/19/2009 — Time Magazine's Karen Tumulty discusses Sen. Reid's health care bill. Time - Health - United States - Health Policy - Anti-Regulation
Nelson seems unlikely to block health debate
journalstar.com 11/18/2009 — A Senate filibuster blocking debate on proposed health care reform legislation likely would lead to a worse bill, Sen. Ben Nelson said Wednesday. If opponents prevent consideration of the revised Senate Finance Committee legislation, he said, ...
Lieberman: Dems Haven't Given Up Enough On Health Care
huffingtonpost.com 12/13/2009 — Senator Joseph Lieberman (I-Conn.) encouraged Democratic leadership in the Senate to wipe health care legislation clean of provisions held dear by progressives (and the majority of Democrats) in order to get reform passed on a bipartisan basis.  ...
Medicare and the Senate Health-Care Debate - Health Blog
blogs.wsj.com 12/8/2009 — Health Reform The newest idea to come out of the Senate’s health-care negotiations isn’t new at all: Allow people age 55 to 64 to buy into Medicare if they can’t get insurance elsewhere. The politics of the proposal are straightforward. The public ...
Senate Agrees To Debate Health Care Bill
tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com 11/22/2009 — On a perfectly partisan, 60-39 vote, the Senate agreed tonight to debate and amend a far-reaching health care bill. That debate will get started in earnest after Congress returns from next week's Thanksgiving recess. Democrats and Republicans expect ...
Health Care Experts
healthcare.nationaljournal.com 12/2/2009 — Health Care: Carper To Unveil New Public Option Measure• "A new measure on the public option will be unveiled next week, which Senate Democratic leaders hope will break the logjam on healthcare reform," The Hill reports. "Sen. Tom Carper (D-Del.), who ...
Congressional Dems Start Pinning Blame For Health Care Fiasco On Obama
theplumline.whorunsgov.com 12/16/2009 — Little by little, Congressional Dems are beginning to pin the lion’s share of the blame for the badly weakened health care bill on a single figure: President Obama. Here’s Russ Feingold, for instance, making a striking accusation: Obama ...
Dems Have 60 for Health Care; Lincoln a 'Yes'TIME.com Top Politics Stories 11/21/2009
Democrats have hit the magic number of 60 to move ahead on historic health care legislation.
Dems get their 60 -- TONIGHTFirst Read 11/22/2009
From NBC's Domenico MontanaroAfter hours of debating whether to allow debate to begin, the Senate voted in favor of letting that happen on the healthcare vote tonight along partisan lines, 60-39.The outcome had become all but assured when Sen. Blanche ...
Senate health care bill clears key hurdleCNN Political Ticker 11/22/2009
WASHINGTON (CNN) - The Senate voted 60-39 Saturday night to proceed with a floor debate on Majority Leader Harry Reid's $848 billion health care bill. The successful vote to prevent a Republican filibuster against starting debate ...
Senator, Clout Rising, Cements Role at Heart of DebateNYT > Politics 11/22/2009
In advance of her re-election bid next year, Blanche Lincoln of Arkansas sided with her fellow Democrats for one vote, but was cautious about the overall health bill.